Premiere Pro 26.3 vs 26.5 read Sony XAVC 50p start timecode differently — all sequence clips slip when a project moves between versions
Hello Adobe Premiere Pro team,
I am a professional editor. I would like to report a timecode bug that silently damages edited sequences. I need it fixed with a patch.
Summary
The same project opened in two Premiere Pro versions reads a different start timecode for the same Sony media file. Premiere keeps each clip's in/out as absolute timecode. When the project is opened in the other version, every edited clip slips inside the source media by up to about 0.5 seconds. Timeline positions stay the same, but the content no longer matches the edit: words are cut and shots start late or early. Nothing warns the user.
Environment
- Machine A (home): Premiere Pro 26.5 (shown as "26.5.2x5" in the project file), Windows 11
- Machine B (work): Premiere Pro 26.3 (shown as "26.3.2x2" in the project file), Windows
- The project is on an external drive and is opened directly on both machines
- Camera: Sony ILME-FX3A, XAVC HS 4K 3840x2160, 50.00p, HEVC 4:2:2 10-bit, LPCM audio, card structure M4ROOT/CLIP with sidecar CxxxxM01.XML
- Sidecar timecode:
LtcChangeTable tcFps="25" halfStep="true" - The media timecode track (ffprobe) shows 50 fps based frame numbers, e.g. 17:33:13:46
What happens
Example file C4582.MP4, timecode track 17:33:13:46 at 50p:
- 26.3 stores the media start (
<Media><Start>) as 17:33:13.92 s. This is correct: 46 frames / 50 = 0.92 s. - 26.5 stores it as 17:33:13.46 s. The frame number 46 is treated as hundredths of a second.
The difference is always "timecode frame number / 100" seconds. We checked this on about 60 different source files in one project, and every file follows the rule exactly. Files whose timecode frame number is 00, and files without timecode (DJI drone clips), do not move.
Because in/out points are kept as absolute timecode, each clip's offset into the media changes by that difference when the project is opened in the other version.
Steps to reproduce
- Import Sony FX3 50p XAVC HS clips with a non-zero start timecode frame number in Premiere Pro 26.5 and make cuts in a sequence.
- Save the project and open it in Premiere Pro 26.3. All cuts now show different content (shifted by frame number / 100 s).
- Fix the cuts by hand, save, and open the project again in 26.5. All the fixed cuts slip again, in the opposite direction.
Impact
I lost a full day re-trimming a long interview sequence by hand, twice. The slip is small enough to miss on a quick look but large enough to cut words. Any project moved between versions, or opened in a future update, is at risk.
Request
- Please confirm which version reads the start timecode of these Sony 50p (25 fps + halfStep) files correctly. Our measurements match 26.3; 26.5 appears to read the frame number as hundredths of a second.
- Please release a patch so that all versions read the same, correct start timecode.
- Please make sure that existing projects saved with the wrong value are not shifted again by the fix. Either convert them correctly, or warn the user and offer to keep the clip content in place.
I can provide a sample clip with its sidecar XML and before/after project files on request.
Best regards,
Burak BULUT
