Skip to main content
Participant
September 16, 2023
Open for Voting

FireFly really poor at generating people images, and following scene instructions.

  • September 16, 2023
  • 22 replies
  • 6063 views

The product doesn't not illustrate the verbal description. Believe that you should allow a user-uploaded picture or one of the previously generated pictures to be uploaded (or check) as the starting point for further refinement. There needs to be a way of ranking the 4 choices provides from worst to best, and have the best used for the next iteration of the image. People generation is by far the weakest link of this program. The people are in no way realistic. Some have three feet, some have donkey legs, nobody has a face. Useless for creating a scene with people in it. I am extremely unimpressed by this program in its current state 9/2023. When a newer release that learns how to read and follow instructions is available, I would like to evaluate it again. For now, it's crap and a time-waster. 

22 replies

Participant
December 20, 2024

Bing is a free option, Midjourney is not. 

Participating Frequently
December 20, 2024

No, it's not. Midjourney generates perfect images of people and scenery. 

Participant
December 20, 2024

Firefly is really bad creating vehicles. Bings image creator (Copilot...) is much better.

 

(mustang 1969 in a livingroom with two penguins beside it)

 

Same image promt with Firefly (the set up in the image is perhaps better, but thats it)

Participant
December 20, 2024

Create base image in Firefly then take it to Photoshop and refine it. Works somewhat ok.

Participant
September 6, 2024

It seems to be the issue with just about any image generator out there including Midjourney. AI image generation is still faaaaaaaaaar away from being used in real client works. AI image generators are for now a wish or a nice-to-haves but the quality of images generated using those technologies remains incredibly poor and primitive. Personally, I can't believe people hop on paid plans for image generation.

Known Participant
July 22, 2024

Then they have the absolute brass nexk NERVE to make it a credit system, so not only are we having to rent software that gets increasingly worse, we have to pay extra for broken features.  I almost can't believe Adobe hasn't failed as a business, they are so bad at EVERYTHING! 

Participant
July 22, 2024

"Formula one car" promt Adobe vs Midourney. 

 

Participant
July 22, 2024

Adobes AI is a joke. You cannot even generate realistic car, or human, or anything. How they even can say its AI because child can draw better.

Participant
April 24, 2024

I forgot to mention, it seemed to do OK with people when I tried it in beta around December 2023.

Participant
April 24, 2024

Even worse when you ask for people running. They're all melting Picasso-esquely and have spaghetti legs. The latter might be because I asked for college students so naturally they're all in skinny jeans.