Skip to main content
Julio Dojo
Participating Frequently
January 14, 2022
Open for Voting

AE: Group Layers without Pre-Composing

  • January 14, 2022
  • 17 replies
  • 8882 views

Dear Community,

Dear After Effects Team @Adobe

 

Why is there still no way to group layers without pre-composing within a single composition?

I imagine it to function just like groups in Photoshop, where you expand a group to reveal all layers within. This will open up entirely new workflows.

 

I came across a plugin created by Petter Bergmar called "FoldLayers": https://vimeo.com/121569449

Is it really this complicated to natively implement such a functionality into After Effects?

 

Can wait to receive aducated reponses.

Kind regards

17 replies

Mylenium
Legend
January 14, 2022

Grouping soemthing visually is not a problem, but apparently one would have to define what groups are supposed to do in terms of functionality with things how they affect render order, transform operations and a gazillion scenarios with combinations of layer switches, effects, time manipulation and so on that regular users who never have dug so deep aren't even aware of. This debate has been going on for literally as long as AE exists and will likely go on fo just as long in the future. As an oldschool guy I'm already loathe of the many things added in recent years like the pointless compositing options which only muddy up a stringent workflow, so I'm definitely pretty much opposed to any major changes and introducing layr groups in teh timeline. For me it really comes back to what I've been saying for forever: People need to learn to see pre-compositions and other stuff as valuable tools, not their enemy they need to avoid or look for ways around. That's pretty much all there is to say on the matter.

 

Mylenium

Julio Dojo
Participating Frequently
January 24, 2022

Hey Mylenium,

 

Can you explain how grouping smth visually isn't a problem?

If you have any workaround you can share, I'd love to hear it.

 

I didn't know that this topic was long debate among Adobe users, even more so it's dissapointing that there still is no good way to do so. If grouping smth visually isn't a big problem, I don't see how this would introduce major changes to AE.

 

I understand your point, but it's always situational and I believe in some cases it really wouldn't hurt to have that option.

E.g. working in a complex main comp with lots of pre-comps inside, I don't understand why diving from pre-comp to pre-comp, to finally reach the comp you'd like to adjust, but then not beeing able to see the effects of your adjustments in the overall picture... in my opinion and in some cases it's just confusing and to helping the "stringent workflow".

 

Julio

Inspiring
January 14, 2022

GM FoldLayers looks pretty neat.

 

When I've seen this discussed it's been that people effectively want to be able to 'twirl open' a precomp and see it's layers visible in the current comp. This is very different from FoldLayers (which just appears to use AE's Shy Layers system to show/hide layers) in that you'd be able to affect the group of layers by altering that main layer (i.e. the way a precomp becomes a single layer in the current comp). But there are potential  issues with this, notably that you could keyframe a Time Remap onto that comp layer to change the timings of the contents, so if you were to twirl open that precomp the keyframes in it wouldn't be at times that represented the remapping occuring on the 'group layer' which would make for some potentially unintuitive editing behaviour.

 

I can't say for sure but I perhaps the reason we haven't seen it is because there's this expectation for what it would need to be able to do that would be considerably more complex to implement. Why do it in this more basic way when third-parties are already perfectly able to implement it themselves?

Julio Dojo
Participating Frequently
January 24, 2022

Hello Paul,

 

thank you for taking the time and repyling. Much appreciated!

I see the potential issues that you are refereing to. However Adobe could make it functional in this way, that it had some limitations, when for example trying to time remap the grouped layer, this then simple wouldn't be possible. So If you tried to time remap you'd have to precomp. 

 

I am thinking of warp stabilizier in PR for example. If you are trying to change speed/duration of any clip in PR with warp stabilizier applied, Premiere simply tells you, that this isn't possible, thereby forcing you to first nest your clip and then apply the speed/duration effect...and people have found there ways to work in this sort of fashion. So why not make it similarly workable in AE.

 

Unfortunately the Plugin GM FoldLayers has been discontinued from development and won't work in the newer version of AE. So at this moment in time, there isn't really any alternative.