Skip to main content
Inspiring
October 19, 2017
Released

P: Ability to sync Lightroom Classic keywords with the Lightroom Ecosystem

  • October 19, 2017
  • 375 replies
  • 17480 views

Keywords do not sync correctly: When added on the mobile app (iOS), they do not appear in LR classic and not in LR Web (I deleted the new LR CC immediately, this version does not make sense to me).
Same problem into the other direction: Keywords from LR classic do not appear on the mobile app. 
Attention: At this stage the whole keywording within the iOS app should not be used!

375 replies

Participating Frequently
September 23, 2018
There is also a point that you all miss here : Lr CC relies on AI to describe the contents of the pictures. IMHO, Adobe wants to put all the efforts in this area, and not cope anymore with classical - and let's be honest - outdated tasks like keywording.
Participating Frequently
September 23, 2018
The correct words I mean are : "Obviously I'm sure it is limited by design (as declared) to be sure keywording will not be use for users to exit the adobe ecosystem."
This is MHO, maybe I'm wrong (I hope)
Participating Frequently
September 23, 2018
You're right!
I've forget the word "only" or something like this. I don't know hoe to edit my words
Antoine HLMN
Inspiring
September 23, 2018
"but to be sure keywording will not be use for users to exit the adobe ecosystem."
--> so it is by design, no?
anothertal3
Inspiring
September 23, 2018
Or Adobe could simply keep the hierarchy by internally storing something like "City>Los Angeles".

You are able to export and import hierarchical keyword lists to files using LR CC with no issues but they say they are unable to do something similar via the internet?

Interesting reasoning...
Participating Frequently
September 23, 2018
Obviously I'm sure it is not limited by design (as declared) but to be sure keywording will not be use for users to exit the adobe ecosystem.
What I mean adobe is turning LR from desktop to full cloud. As a result they will justify the price because of cloud cost and not because of functionality.

And without full keyword management (which is a total open management system usable by every software or the finder/explorer) we will not be able to switch to an another system/ecosystem

So they will ensure a permanent revenue.

I don't know darktable, maybe I will have to give a try.
Or maybe the file management of Luminar? 

But actually LR CC is near unusable to manage / catalog photos but develop photos
Antoine HLMN
Inspiring
September 23, 2018
To be honest, the only thing that keeps me with LR right now are:
1) Too lazy struggle with a switch to another platform (darktable looks fabulous, though!)
2) Sync between LR mobile and desktop

Number one can easily be solved. And If the next versions of LR is not a big improvement (speed, functions, sync, ...) my laziness will decrease quite quickly. Number two could also easily be solved
Known Participant
September 23, 2018
I agree. But this could be the "one too much" mischief from Adobe against customers ans push them to go and watch elsewhere. Darktable ?...
Antoine HLMN
Inspiring
September 22, 2018
Of course! Stating it's a technical issue is taking people for idiots. Insulting! How to do it best? I don't know, it's not my business. But I do know it is not technically impossible or even that difficult.

The sad part is, it is a political / marketing / business / ... decision.

The even sadder part is: LR classic is probably going to die slowly to force people to switch to a full cloud based app.
Participating Frequently
September 21, 2018
What I read here is crazy after 11 months! I think it should be easy to flatten the hierarchy to allow sync
I should be easy for every developer, no?

For example
"master keyword" and "sub keyword" become "master keyword.sub keyword"

For example _ 
Landscape/mountain
Landscape/river
Lanscape/forest in Classic become 3 flatten keyword in CC during sync :
Landscape.mountain
Landscape.river
Lanscape.forest

Resulting in a full flaten syncable keywording.
So Adobe will not need to implement so much functionality in CC and we will live with the 2 software to composate CC desktop wekness
No?