Skip to main content
Participating Frequently
Apr 27, 2011 1:17 PM UTC
Open for Voting

P: Better auto stacking for bracketing, HDR, Focus Stacking and Panoramas

I currently shoot a lot of Bracketed shots for exposure blending, and with each shot having a different shutter speed the auto-stacking can fail to accurately stack the grouped shots - especially when the shutter speed gets up into 10+ seconds!I would love an option for Auto Stacking to work on the time delay between the shutter closing and the shutter opening again, so it is a true measure of the gap between shots. In this way I can auto-stack on all bracketed shots even when the shutter speed is seconds long. Calculate the time between shots by adding the shutter speed to the capture time of the first shot, and then compare this to the capture time of the next shot, and if I am using Continuous shooting, this gap will be only a fraction of a second, regardless of the shutter speed.Gary

82 replies

Participating Frequently
Sep 24, 2020 4:54 PM UTC

@pecohen If not automatically adding a tag, let me flag the first (and perhaps the last image) of a series

Translate
Pacoh
Known Participant
Sep 24, 2020 12:41 PM UTC

One thing that would be a big help would be for camera manufacturers to tag the bracketed shots, perhaps with an index number and maybe even an indication of what kind of bracketing is in use.  Then LR could accurately stack those bracketed shots.

 

This would not cover all cases, but then again neither can auto-stacking hope for that.   

Translate
Inspiring
Sep 24, 2020 12:26 PM UTC

Yes... and if the comparison doesn't work programmatically, then ask the user how many images are in each bracket. 

Translate
Sean H [Seattle branch]
Known Participant
Sep 23, 2020 9:09 PM UTC

My background is image processing. The HDR really isn't that hard. They have metadata to work with. They can see sequential shots with specific exposure changes... 1 stop, 2/3 stop, 1/3 stop... LR already looks at this with the "Match Total Exposures". LR could further inspect the images for overlapping features. In fact, this would be very simple because they can find features in the first and then confine their search space in the successive images rather than running the entire array in the successive images. 

 

Panos would simply require a large kernel and quick pass rough feature matching.  

 

A combination of the above approaches wouldn't be significantly more difficult. 

Translate
[ ◉"]
Participating Frequently
Sep 23, 2020 8:32 PM UTC

@Rikk Auto stacking we are referring to, is not stacking when I manual processing the image but rather identify the images that should be stacked together to form an HDR image, a panoramic image (harder), a HDR panoramic image (much much harder), or a focus stack (again harder).

 

Might ask the user when type of auto stacks they are looking for.

Translate
Participating Frequently
Sep 23, 2020 8:31 PM UTC

Auto stacking for HDR should be rather simple, check change in exposure, in particular shutter speed, small time step between the end of the one image and the start of the next.  Look for groupings of 2, 3, 4, 5 with predictable set of changes in shutter speed.  Might even do a quick comparison of the images to assure that they overlap (or batch process).

 

Auto stacking for focus stacking and panoramic is harder but doable if overlaps are checked.

Translate
Participating Frequently
Jan 16, 2020 8:04 PM UTC
Cannot believe this is such an old thread ... and the problems are still there!
Translate
Inspiring
Jan 16, 2020 12:54 PM UTC
Auto-stacking by number of pictures would seem to be so simple to implement. I'm coming from Corel's much inferior Aftershot, which DOES have this feature. Surprised to see that LR doesn't!
Translate
Participant
Aug 18, 2019 12:23 PM UTC


It's great that you have enabled batch processing of HDR and Pano images. A great next step in efficiency would to be able to auto-stack an entire folder of bracketed images.

Often I have very large folders of images that are full of bracketed images of the same sequence quantity. To use the nice batch HDR merge feature, I first need to manually stack hundreds of images to use that feature. I wish I could just select all and choose an option to auto-stack "every x images" where "x" is user defined. 
Translate
Inspiring
Aug 18, 2019 12:21 PM UTC


A feature to automatically stack photos before merging. The new HDR batch feature added in version 8.4 isn't useful from a time savings perspective. It actually introduces two extra steps to create a merged file, (first create the stack, then select all Stacks for the merge).

Why couldn't Adobe create an automated merge process where you simply select all photos you want merged and then define how many photos there are per bracket? It could then use that information to automatically create Stacks and perform the merge based on that. Other HDR programs do something similar automatically.
Translate