Skip to main content
D
Dark_Phoenix_Photography
Participant
April 8, 2021
Open for Voting

P: Bring back "Shake Reduction" filter - Removed in Photoshop v.23.3.0

  • April 8, 2021
  • 188 replies
  • 76164 views

Änderungen am Programm ohne die User zu fragen - "Verwacklung reduzieren" in PS v.23.3.0 entfallen?

 

Mittlerweile ist man es als User gewohnt, dass Adobe Änderungen an Photoshop und Co. vornimmt.

Erst der "Fehler" seit Anfang Februar, dass die Ebenen bei der Nutzung von Color Lookup´s schwarz sind und somit nicht nutzbar (das Problem habe ich nach zwei Monaten endlich selbst gelöst) und nun fehlt schlicht und einfach wieder ein Scharfzeichnungsfilter, den viele wahrscheinlich nicht häufg nutzen, ich jedoch als finales Schärfen, diesen "Verwacklung reduzieren" mit Vorliebe eingesetzt habe.

 

Heute am Rechner, Bilder vom Ostersonntagmorgen mit Monduntergang, sitze hier, bearbeite und ... bin überrascht, dass ich meinen Filter nicht mehr finde.

 

Falls dieser doch noch irgendwo sein sollte, mal wieder irgendwo ganz hinten drin versteckt, bin ich dankbar für jeden Tipp.

 

Liebe Grüße und ein schönes Osterfest...
Gordon

    This topic has been closed for replies.

    188 replies

    Show previous replies
    M
    Mike5FD817752762
    Participating Frequently
    April 30, 2022
    Both sharpening and noise reduction do strange things to the pixels in the
    image. My guess is that the shake reduction filter somehow puts the pixels
    back in proper position which they should have been in if there were no
    shake to begin with. The image looks sharper but the filter really isn't
    shapened in the traditional sense. I've tried many times to emulate the
    shake reduction filter and haven't found a solution yet. Even the Topaz
    version isn't nearly as good.
    janetm62681729
    janetm62681729
    Known Participant
    April 30, 2022

    you have to do it manually... sharpen the image, then do noise reduction..as a final step i then do the FILTER-SHARPEN-SMART SHARPEN....

    G
    giP17213482
    Inspiring
    April 29, 2022
    Exactly. How to use 2 versions without a lot of time consuming switching back and forth.
      M
      Mike5FD817752762
      Participating Frequently
      April 29, 2022

      I reverted back but I will have to figure out another solution sometime in the future if Adobe introduces any new, must-have, features.  I was even thinking of partitionaing my C drive and loading 2 instances of windows and operate them simultaneously, one with the old version of PS and one with the latest updated version.  Caveat, I don't know how to do this.  

        T
        tobylong
        Known Participant
        April 29, 2022

        Anyone else missing Shake reduction filter under Filter - Sharpen? I think it dissapeared after the last update. Using PC on Latest Windows 10.

          Ged_Traynor
          Community Expert
          Ged_TraynorCommunity Expert
          Community Expert
          April 29, 2022

          Hi

          It's been removed in version 23.3

            T
            tobylong
            Known Participant
            April 29, 2022

            That's a shame. It was very useful. I wonder if there's an alternative method.

              W
              Wilson Laidlaw
              Known Participant
              April 28, 2022

              Topaz Sharpen AI is pretty good for shake reduction but not as convenient to use as the late lamented PS filter and a fair bit slower. From what I experience, it runs quite a bit faster on my M1 Macs (MBA and Mini) than it seems to on my Intel MBP. 

                B
                Bund josh
                Known Participant
                April 28, 2022
                Hi,

                I agree on the bring-back shake reduction. I use to use it all the time.

                But, now I use Topaz and use the smart sharpen in photoshop with motion
                blur and change the angles. This helps but shake reduction was easy and
                best!
                --
                Atul Joshi MD, FRCS, MCh(Ortho)
                  John Young Photography
                  John Young Photography
                  Known Participant
                  April 28, 2022

                  Topaz Sharpen AI is very good - they have a free trial

                   

                  https://www.topazlabs.com/sharpen-ai

                  B
                  brcssc
                  Known Participant
                  April 28, 2022

                  I edit lots of old photos.. those back when the film ASA 64 was the norm.  Shake is a major problem with all of those photos and the only tool I have found that works with that was Photoshop Shake Reduction.  This really sucks that you have removed this extremely useful tool.  None of the other tools seem to provide that particular function.

                    S
                    sharon and byroc38737634
                    Participant
                    April 28, 2022

                    Per the notes below, Shake reduction has been removed intentionally for all of Photoshop users, (Windows or Mac)  I am very unhappy with the removal of the Shake Reduction Filter.  While  I use Topaz Sharpen AI, there are times that the Shake Reduction worked far better.  If it is inacompatible with the new technnology, you need to  recreate a way for the old tools to be used.  Among other things, Topaz AI can take up to 30 minutes to work while the Shake Reduction Filter only took a small fraction of that time.

                     

                    Bring it back!

                      Show more replies
                      Terms & ConditionsAccessibility statement
                      Using the community Terms of use Privacy Cookie preferences Do not sell or share my personal information ad choicesAdChoices