Skip to main content
dublove
Legend
October 21, 2024
Open for Voting

Why doesn't Photoshop have color styles? A style controls multiple objects.

  • October 21, 2024
  • 19 replies
  • 1054 views

Why doesn't Photoshop have color styles? A style controls multiple objects.
I don't know why the color palette is not modifiable in the software?
I would like to use one color style to control the color of multiple objects and be able to change my color at any time.
Like the swatch feature in InDesing and Illustrator?
The swatches in PS only seem to be able to add, not modify color values?

 

Also, the existing styles feature is only add-on, you can't modify existing styles.

 

Very curious to ask, what is the PS development team thinking?

19 replies

davescm
Community Expert
Community Expert
November 16, 2024

But that does not give you what you asked for which was the flexibility similar to illustrator where you can change the colour of any object, anywhere in the layerstack, that is linked to a global colour.

 

Dave

dublove
dubloveAuthor
Legend
November 16, 2024

Thank you very much.
This method is not very good.
Another method might be more flexible than this.
Layer>Insert Fill Layer>Solid Color and change the layer mode to “Filter Color”.

 

From what you guys are saying, it's logistically unlikely, but the  color has a fixed value and should be easy to implement.
It mostly depends, if Adobe wants to do it or not.

 

davescm
Community Expert
Community Expert
November 16, 2024

It should have been a PSD but with changes to cloud storage it hasn't worked that way.

I've sent you a PM with a link on WeTransfer. It should be valid for a couple of days

 

Dave

dublove
dubloveAuthor
Legend
November 16, 2024

The example is a pdf?
It should be psd or tif.

davescm
Community Expert
Community Expert
November 16, 2024

@jane-e  Thanks Jane, I've changed the permissions - can you let me know if that was worked?

Dave

jane-e
Community Expert
Community Expert
November 16, 2024

@davescm 

 

This is what I get when I click your link:

 

Jane

davescm
Community Expert
Community Expert
November 16, 2024

If you meant the example I gave above I've linked it here

Edit - Link removed see later post.

Dave

dublove
dubloveAuthor
Legend
November 16, 2024

It feels a little complicated. Not very understandable.
Is there an example file?
Maybe we can only expect Adobe to be more advanced.

Stephen Marsh
Community Expert
Community Expert
November 16, 2024

IMHO, this only makes sense for text, vectors, gradient fills, solid fills, etc., not for rasters.

davescm
Community Expert
Community Expert
November 16, 2024

It would not be straightforward to implement as it would require a set of swatches to be tagged as global (simple to do) and then any pixel made from those swatches, be they brushed on a layer, added with a blending option..etc, to be tagged back to that swatch. In a multi-layer document that would involve an awful lot of tags (1 per pixel affected) and would increase memory use considerably as well as slowing down the performance of brushes. (In short very hard to implement).
Finally it would require changes to the PSD/PSB format. In illustrator the swatches are saved in the AI document. In Photoshop they are not, hence the need to store them in the file format, and make them available in the swatch panel on opening, so that they could be adusted later. (Again very hard to implement in an existing, widely compatible, doc format).

 

Nothing is impossible, but the changes in structure and file formats, which would affect PSD/PSB readabilty in other Adobe and non-Adobe applications, make this far from simple, and the associated performance hit when brushing could be high.

 

Dave