Skip to main content
hilbrandbos
Participating Frequently
June 27, 2022
Open for Voting

Why is it not possible to keep the masks made in Camera RAW or import them as photoshop layers?

  • June 27, 2022
  • 15 replies
  • 2355 views

Why is it not possible to hold on to the mask that you so carefully make while importing the image into photoshop. For instance:

 

I have a photo with a human subject. I drag it into photoshop. I make two masks, one for the subject and one inverse. I apply my tonal adjustance to each of the masks. Why can't I keep these masks when I import the raw file to a photoshop file? Now I have to recreate these masks again, which means I do the same job twice? What kind of design is this? If I hate one thing it's doing double work. 

15 replies

hilbrandbos
Participating Frequently
June 27, 2022

I thought of that workaround too, but it is still cumbersome. I felt I was quicker with the quick selection tools, but that is pretty much doing the same work as in Camera raw... 

JohanElzenga
Community Expert
Community Expert
June 27, 2022

Like I said; that would require a major rewrite of ACR. It's not a matter of 'just' changing a few lines of code. Maybe Adobe will do that one day, AFAIK you are not the first person who suggested this.

 

-- Johan W. Elzenga
davescm
Community Expert
Community Expert
June 27, 2022

What you've just described would require layer support.

 

As a work around take the raw image into Photoshop as a smart object. Then open the SO and make an extreme adjustment using the camera raw mask - for example turn everything in the mask black and everything outside white. Then you can use that output to make a selection/mask in Photoshop and save it as a channel. Then go back into the SO and undo the extreme adjustments.

 

Dave

hilbrandbos
Participating Frequently
June 27, 2022

Camera Raw doesn't need to work with layers. It just needs to export an amount of images with the contents masked out corresponding to the amount of masks and preferably put those images in one layered file.

JohanElzenga
Community Expert
Community Expert
June 27, 2022

Camera Raw does not support layers, so it cannot send out a masked (= layered) image to Photoshop. It would require a major rewrite of Camera Raw, so that is why this is not possible (yet?). It would be nice, though.

 

-- Johan W. Elzenga