Skip to main content

72 replies

Participant
Nov 8, 2024 8:39 PM UTC

Wow such a basic feature and adobe doesn't have it? Now im seriously considering going back to capcut

Translate
Known Participant
Nov 6, 2024 1:05 AM UTC

I'm reaching this thread today as my workflow has largely shifted to social media clients; automatic beat detection for these short cut-downs would be incredibly useful. There's a reason this thread has OVER 2,500 eyes on it. People need this feature. This is a basic audio fundamental that plugins are taking over when I already spend over $500 a year on Premiere and Adobe apps. This is embarrasing for this "professional" software.

Translate
Participant
Sep 8, 2024 5:26 PM UTC

AI has entered the chat... 

Translate
MyerPj
Community Expert
Community Expert
Sep 6, 2024 7:56 PM UTC

Oh, my.... 😐

 

Translate
Thai Mac
Participating Frequently
Jun 3, 2024 3:40 AM UTC

I would say 80% of trending social media reels and videos are made where scene transitions are dependant on the audio beat. We must not be talking about the same thing as it's extremely perplexing that anyone is even debating this.

Translate
MyerPj
Community Expert
Community Expert
Jun 3, 2024 3:37 AM UTC

I'm with Neil. I don't think it's a fundamental issue. I have ears that tell me where the beats are.

Translate
R Neil Haugen
Legend
Jun 3, 2024 2:54 AM UTC

It's a basic function to you, but one that most editors will never use.  I would have no issue with adding as an effect, understand, I'm all for adding new stuff.  I'm explaining why it's not already there.

 

I think a lot of color tools should "already be there" in Premiere, that sadly, most editors would never use. But at least, I'm realistic about the percentage of people who would actually use the stuff I'd love to have. Not ... very many, truthfully.

Translate
Everyone's mileage always varies ...
Thai Mac
Participating Frequently
Jun 3, 2024 2:08 AM UTC

Auto beats detection is a basic fundamental audio function that should be native. It shouldn't be dependant on a 3rd party add-on - regardless of costs.

Translate
R Neil Haugen
Legend
Jun 3, 2024 2:05 AM UTC

The "pro" apps have tended to assume that one either controls such things manually or buys plugins for specialized things like this. Like BeatEdit from aescripts.com.

 

As someone who works for/with/teachers pro colorists, with spendy rigs and monitors, working in Resolve or Baselight ... all the folks I work with have the full Boris and probably a couple other "suites" of things available. 

 

Editors seem to think paying a one-timw $25 fee for a plugin outrageous. I find this all rather humorous.

 

And btw ... I've got the full Red Giant Universe, personally ... 

Translate
Everyone's mileage always varies ...
Thai Mac
Participating Frequently
Jun 2, 2024 4:35 PM UTC

Been searching for this too. I'm blown away that in 2024 Adobe doesn't have the capability or technological knowledge to do this. Even Capcut has this feature. It's mindblowing. 

Translate