Skip to main content
Participating Frequently
March 8, 2025
Answered

Criteria for acceptance or termination of submitted works

  • March 8, 2025
  • 5 replies
  • 2631 views

Hello dear experts. I have recently started uploading pictures to this resource. I do some things myself, and some things with the help of AI. It seems that the approval or denial to upload an image depends entirely on a particular moderator, who is currently working on the shift. Some specialist will accept and some specialist will not.  In the beginning I didn't really pay attention to details, errors, and artifacts in the image. Then, thanks to your forum began to study and carefully approach to all the nuances. I have previously accepted works on the resource, which now I would not even upload myself, because of their obviously poor quality. But they were accepted. So I am not quite clear about the selection criteria. Today I had nine images of the same subject rejected at once. Images of toy teddy bears on a transparent background. They are made with AI, in the same style. It took me a long time to process them. The reason for rejection is quality problems. Standard version. And so I have a big request to you - please point out my mistakes in the work that I would not repeat them. I will provide one image with a robot, which was accepted, but clearly does not meet the requirements. And two images with bears on a transparent background, which were rejected. I really need some clues on the bears. Thank you for your time. And thank you in advance.

Correct answer Abambo

The red line helps identifying easy to miss issues with cut-outs. With a clean cut-out, you would see only a single thin line around the object. The effect here in this asset looks like you, using an automatic background remover. 

 

Check also here the corners. Some of the initial background survived.

5 replies

Legend
March 9, 2025

I think the reasons for rejections are the irrigular stitching and the cut out as Abambo points out.

Participant
March 10, 2025

Stitching needs to improve to show its neatness.

Abambo
Community Expert
Community Expert
March 9, 2025

Just checking a small part of 5555, I see multiple issues in the texture and in the cutout work. You should start learning, how to do cutoutwork on sharp edges. 

ABAMBO | Hard- and Software Engineer | Photographer
Abambo
Community Expert
Community Expert
March 9, 2025

Just looking at my post a second time, and I see additional cutout errors. Doung cutouts is time consuming. That's the reason, why some prefer correctly cutout assets, instead of doing the hard work themselves.

ABAMBO | Hard- and Software Engineer | Photographer
Abambo
Community Expert
Community Expert
March 9, 2025
quote

It seems that the approval or denial to upload an image depends entirely on a particular moderator, who is currently working on the shift.


By @AviPicBox

Which one of the few thousand moderators do you mean? If you look at the database growth, there is no doubt that Adobe needs to occupy a lot of moderators. Chances are, that you never get the same moderator twice.

ABAMBO | Hard- and Software Engineer | Photographer
Jill_C
Community Expert
Community Expert
March 8, 2025

The bears are really cute, and with a few minor edits, I'm sure they would be accepted. This one has inconsistent button eyes.

Jill C., Forum Volunteer
AviPicBoxAuthor
Participating Frequently
March 8, 2025
Thank you very much for highlighting the errors. I will correct them. And thank you again.
daniellei4510
Community Expert
Community Expert
March 8, 2025

I'm going to be as picky as the moderator of these image probably was, since it only takes one error to result in a rejection.  Also, it should be noted that "teddy bear" is trademarked by the Vermont Teddy Bear Company, so I'd avoid using the term in your titles and keywords.

 

Adobe Community Expert | If you can't fix it, hide it; if you can't hide it, delete it.
AviPicBoxAuthor
Participating Frequently
March 8, 2025

Thank you very much for considering my request. I uploaded the robot picture to the forum to exemplify both my error and the moderator's error. I didn't pay attention to such nuances at the time. This is a clear error. This error is visible to everyone. In addition to the hand you circled, there are lots and lots of other flaws there. But nevertheless this picture was accepted on the resource. The moderator accepted it. And this picture is on the site. You can see it in my profile. That's the point. There's an extra fifth hole in the button of the bear. I will correct this error and upload the image to the resource. Thank you again for your answer and advice. Sincerely, Alex.

AviPicBoxAuthor
Participating Frequently
March 8, 2025
 apologize for the picture with the robot. It was not published. Sorry again.