Skip to main content
Participant
December 24, 2021
Question

First lot of rejections - My initial reaction - [too] picky!!!

  • December 24, 2021
  • 7 replies
  • 631 views

so posted my first 30 and all rejected. . What the heck - 5 attached

 

Please advise!

 

[Subject edited by moderator as per forum guidelines.]

This topic has been closed for replies.

7 replies

Abambo
Community Expert
Community Expert
December 26, 2021

(...)334: hig noise level, but still not  sharp:

(...)497: high noise level. 

(...)609: out of focus 

(...)491: high noise level and out of focus. 

 

I do not think that DoF is a problem. You have a focussing problem and at least part of your pictures show different other defects. No "what's the heck". All pictures have been rightfully rejected. You need to pay more attention to the detail. And you need to critically examine your pictures at 100% and 200%. You will see defects at that magnification. 

ABAMBO | Hard- and Software Engineer | Photographer
Nancy OShea
Community Expert
Community Expert
December 24, 2021

The last image is underexposed, the colors have low saturation and the focus is too blurry probably due to camera shake and shallow depth-of-field.   You might get better results with a tripod and longer exposure.

 

Adobe Stock customers expect the highest visual and technical quality for use in commercial projects.  Please read the Contributor User Guide for more details.


Better luck next time. 🙂

Nancy O'Shea— Product User & Community Expert
Participant
December 24, 2021

Thanks for all your comments. something to think on. My counter comments where Adobe and this community expect more of the shot to be in focus, all the pro pictures you see are at f2.8 then if f5+ is expected then cannot understand the contradiction. . and is which case why everyone chases expensice -f2-3 glass..

reedesign1912
Inspiring
December 24, 2021

Looking at your photo 0334 for example, when you zoom at 100% (which is how all of the customers buying it will look at it) the centre of the flower is not in focus. The focal point seems to be the bottom half of the flower and to the left.  The other problems that present themelves is that the flower seems to be moving in the breeze so you get a bit of motion blur, especially noticeable on the leaves on the left.  There is also a lot of visual noise / grain in the flower petals.  If you are using a shallow depth of field, any technical challenges in the photo are very noticeable.

 

I'm certainly not an expert here, but just offering an opinion.  I've certainly had to remind myself that photos that I think are really interesting, where I've taken artistic license, are not the ones that will sell in stock photography.  From personal experience, specifically in landscape photos I've had the best success with in stock are usually taken at least at f9.

 

 

Rob R, Photographer
Inspiring
December 24, 2021

Respectfully - what are all those white spots all over the first image?  Dust on the sensor?  If this is dust on your sensor, you need to have it cleaned and preferably by a professional who won't damage your camera in the process..  

Jill_C
Community Expert
Community Expert
December 24, 2021

I agree that lack of sharp focus is indeed the main problem. Flowers are very much over-represented in the Adobe Stock database, and for yours to be accepted or ever sold they need to be unique and technically perfect. 

Jill C., Forum Volunteer
PaintedKitty
Community Expert
Community Expert
December 24, 2021

Lots of completion too therefore reviewers are "more picky".

Nice photos btw. 🙂

reedesign1912
Inspiring
December 24, 2021

I only looked at the first few, but in my opinion it's mainly the shallow depth of field which doesn't allow for enough of your subject to be in focus.  The water drops are very cool, but when looking at your photo at 100% hardly anything is in focus.

 

Similarly, your rose with the lovely bokeh seems to have some motion blur along with a lot of noise and shallow depth of field.

 

I hope this helps.  Sorry, I didn't take a close lookat the others.

 

-Rob

 

Rob R, Photographer