For what reason do you think the ai pictures were rejected?

Forum|Forum|2 years ago
February 19, 2024
4 replies
433 views

Can you please comment on the reason for rejecting my AI pictures? I didn't understand because they didn't give a specific reason. And I enlarged the image in 5K and removed the noise. I created it in midjourney. The logos and trademarks are not real there.

Contributor critique

This topic has been closed for replies.

Correct answer Jill_C

The gibberish text needs to be removed. There are drawing errors, particularly in the ribbons.

jacquelingphoto2017

Community Expert

Hi @lotos_land ,

Before submitting your files, zoom in and inspect them.

Best wishes

Jacquelin

Jill_C

Correct answer

Community Expert

The gibberish text needs to be removed. There are drawing errors, particularly in the ribbons.

Jill C., Forum Volunteer

Abambo

Community Expert

Can you please comment on the reason for rejecting my AI pictures? I didn't understand because they didn't give a specific reason.

By @lotos_land

Adobe gives a specific reason for their rejection. You should copy the heading of that here. I suppose it was “Quality Issues”. Which means that you should look into image errors. With generative AI, you often have:

artefacts that you see at 100% of the image size. If you see them before upscaling, you will upscale the artefacts and make them even more prominent.
you can have distortions in geometric objects, especially good visible, when you expect to see parallel lines, round lines, lines to be continued after being hidden behind an object etc.
generative AI is terrible in counting. Hands have 5 fingers, with stool legs are normally 4 required etc.
generative AI cannot write. They put in fake writing with fake characters. Best is to avoid that. If there is fake writing, you should edit that out.
washed out transitions from one (optical) object to another. Colours are not always as clear as they should be.

You have a great mix of those errors in your pictures. Obviously, as you do not show hands and stools, You do not have such an error. But when I look at the decorative ribbons, I see elements that can't be like that or usually aren't. Or, like the corks, that are quite wrong. I would simply get rid of them.

ABAMBO | Hard- and Software Engineer | Photographer

daniellei4510

Community Expert

generative AI cannot write. They put in fake writing with fake characters. Best is to avoid that. If there is fake writing, you should edit that out.

You have a great mix of those errors in your pictures. Obviously, as you do not show hands and stools, You do not have such an error. But when I look at the decorative ribbons, I see elements that can't be like that or usually aren't. Or, like the corks, that are quite wrong. I would simply get rid of them.

By @Abambo

The alpha version 6 of Midjourney has in fact been taught how to write and spell words correctly (at least half of the time). But even when fairly well done, I think we might start seeing a lot of submissions with included text that are going to result in rejections for having even intelligible text included where it doesn't really belong, or because it will still require the usual amount (if not more) of the editing necessary when it comes AI.

Adobe Community Expert | If you can't fix it, hide it; if you can't hide it, delete it.