Known Participant

Answered

I kindly ask for your opinion on the commercial value and quality.

Forum|Forum|1 year ago
December 3, 2024
3 replies
908 views

Following the positive experience and the very helpful feedback I previously received regarding the reasons for the rejection of earlier images, I would like to submit for your consideration some images I have reworked based on those valuable critiques.

I kindly ask for your opinion on whether the quality level is acceptable for AI-generated images and if they hold any commercial value. Specifically, do you think the subject should remain central in the composition, or would it be better placed to the side to leave space for potential clients to add their own content?

Contributor critique

This topic has been closed for replies.

Correct answer jacquelingphoto2017

Hi @Gianni Marcolongo ,

No one knows what the customer will buy. It boils down to what Adobe will accept. The marketers are the best to decide commercial appeal. There are files that Adobe refuse but get sold on other platforms. Therefore, non of us (suppliers) here can tell you if a file does have commercial appeal especially since we do not interact with the customers.

Best wishes

Jacquelin

daniellei4510

Community Expert

I'm curious. Did you select Illustrations or Photos when you submitted these?

Adobe Community Expert | If you can't fix it, hide it; if you can't hide it, delete it.

G

Gianni MarcolongoAuthor

Known Participant

Queste immagini non sono state ancora inviate; Sto cercando il tuo feedback in anticipo. Quelle che ho inviato in precedenza e che sono state rifiutate sono state classificate come immagini, non foto, e identificate come "generate dall'intelligenza artificiale".

daniellei4510

Community Expert

The point I was getting at is this: the backgrounds in each of these images look photo realistic, while the subjects look like cartoons. From a commercial point of view, it should be one or the other throughout. Do a search for "health care workers with arms crossed" to check out your competition.

Adobe Community Expert | If you can't fix it, hide it; if you can't hide it, delete it.

Jill_C

Community Expert

The eyes are not well rendered in either of these - they have sort of a zombie quality. The skin also looks very plastic. I have highlighted a few drawing errors here:

Jill C., Forum Volunteer

G

Gianni MarcolongoAuthor

Known Participant

I truly believe you are right. I underestimated this kind of artifacts. Thank you for your kind critique.

jacquelingphoto2017

Community Expert

Hi @Gianni Marcolongo ,

There are a number of rendering errors.

This is showing the presence of an extra hidden finger.

I don't get the feeling of these fingers making contact with the garment.

The stethoscope edge is not solid

There's an issue with the rendering of the eye, and the left eye corner.

The hair appears too soft for being in the forefront.

Overall the edges of the first file are too soft.

The second file also has rendering issues

There is problem with the eye. What's that looking like a web entangling in the eyelashes?

I'm not sure this is critical, but she's missing a tooth.

The edge of thestethoscope is not continuous and also appears to be broken at the top.

There's an issue with the hair here.

I get the impression of the hair appearing ropey.

You need to zoom in on your files at between 100 and 200% to examine them in details for errors before submitting them.

Best wishes

Jacquelin

G

Gianni MarcolongoAuthor

Known Participant

I truly believe you are right. I underestimated this kind of artifact. Thank you for your kind critique.

What do you think about the subject instead? Could it have commercial appeal? Should the subject be placed to the side, as a central position might limit its usability for the end user?

jacquelingphoto2017

Correct answer

Community Expert

Hi @Gianni Marcolongo ,

No one knows what the customer will buy. It boils down to what Adobe will accept. The marketers are the best to decide commercial appeal. There are files that Adobe refuse but get sold on other platforms. Therefore, non of us (suppliers) here can tell you if a file does have commercial appeal especially since we do not interact with the customers.

Best wishes

Jacquelin

Sign up

To post, reply, or follow discussions, please sign in with your Adobe ID.

Sign in to Adobe Community

To post, reply, or follow discussions, please sign in with your Adobe ID.

Scanning file for viruses.

This file cannot be downloaded