Skip to main content
L
Lillidale
Known Participant
May 18, 2020
Question

Looking for critiques

  • May 18, 2020
  • 1 reply
  • 563 views

Hello, I'm new to submitting photos and to this forum. I recently submitted 12 photos of which 3 were accepted. Most of the ones that were rejected said it was because of unspecified technical issues. I'd love to have someone explain to me what is wrong with them so I can learn what exactly they are looking for. Frankly, two of the ones that were accepted seemed to me of lesser quality than the rejects so clearly I need to learn more about this. Thank you in advance for your help.

This topic has been closed for replies.

1 reply

jacquelingphoto2017
Community Expert
jacquelingphoto2017Community Expert
Community Expert
May 19, 2020

Hi Littik,

The composition of your work seem to be well thought out. However there are a number of issues with all.

Noise/Grain: All images uploaded display excessive noise. This is visible as small dots (color and/or gray) when image is zoomed to between 100 and 200%. 

Technical Issue:

The first image, the cat, give the impression of being altered with the use of post process filters. It that was the case, it would not be acceptable. In addition, there is the matter of purple and green color fringing around the edges.

The next image, the tree, the subjects display not details. It is just a black blab against aqua sky with is in fact not natural. Your photos need to remain as close to being natural as possible. Also there must be visible details of the subjects.

The cathedral wall towards the top right displays multicoloured when examined at between 100 and 200% zoom. The colors of your image must be smooth.

 

Both birds displays blue color fringing at the edges and is especially visible on the metal the the bird lands on.

The deer also display purple color fringes at the edges of its head.

 

Out of focus:

In addition, around the edges of the deer is not sharp. It is out of focus. When zoomed to 100%, the edges of your images should still be sharp.

 

Best wishes

JG

 

L
LillidaleAuthor
Known Participant
May 26, 2020

Thank you very much for your comments. They are extremely helpful. If you don't mind another question, what causes the color fringing on the bird photos? (It was deliberate on the cat )

Lilli

jacquelingphoto2017
Community Expert
jacquelingphoto2017Community Expert
Community Expert
May 26, 2020

Hi Lilli,

You are most welcome.

 

Based on my observation one of the cause is as a result of poor camera settings. Another might have to do with JPG camera processing (if your photos are taken in JPG format). Also it would appear there are times its difficult to avoid even as much as noise cannot be avoided, but minimizes with adequate lighting/exposure.

 

I observe that for shots that are under exposed in the forefront while there is strong back-lighting (for example the shade side of a subject with lighted sky background) is likely to end up with color fringing.

 

Minimum color fringing can be corrected in Cameraraw using the color noise reduction tool and the lens correction tool. However for more advanced issue Photoshop noise filter plugin does a fairly decent job.

 

Best wishes 

JG

 

Terms & ConditionsAccessibility statement
Using the community Terms of use Privacy Cookie preferences Do not sell or share my personal information ad choicesAdChoices