Participant

Answered

Looking for feedback about quality issues

17 replies
515 views
Translate

I would like to learn about quality issues that could be the reason this image was declined.

Thank you

Contributor critique

daniellei4510Correct answer

Community Expert

Haloing and misshapen edges, noticeable even at this size. Slightly underexposed in the shadows.

Adobe Community Expert | I have miles to go before I sleep, but I'm all done on this end.

Nancy OShea

Community Expert

This looks like AI.

The texture on everything is oddly synthetic and unnatural. I would have refused it for that reason alone.

Translate

Nancy O'Shea— Product User & Community Expert

W

wilkasAuthor

Participant

I shuold have mentioned this. Yes, this is ChatGPT made, marked as AI content, with a face transfer (my face) and has a person release 🙂

Translate

daniellei4510

Community Expert

ChatGPT is not my go-to AI platform unless I use it to edit existing AI. It leans heavily on a deep yellow, almost sepia color tint that's difficult to correct.

Translate

Adobe Community Expert | I have miles to go before I sleep, but I'm all done on this end.

daniellei4510

Community Expert

In addition to manual editing, keep in mind you have additional AI options to improve the quality of an asset: ChatGPT, GPT Image (available in Firefly), Gemini 2.5 Flash (a.k.a, Nano Banana, also available in Firefly), Krea (image enhancement) and many others. They all come at an additional cost, of course, but if you're dead set on submitting quality content from crappy or at least less than perfect AI, you'll need to take the plunge. I ran this example through ChatGPT and then manually removed the haloing. Would it be accepted? I dunno. The coat looks a little too stylized and cartoonish, but I think you get the idea.

Translate

Adobe Community Expert | I have miles to go before I sleep, but I'm all done on this end.

Abambo

Community Expert

😂 @daniellei4510 : No, check the cheek! And the skin texture is still bad. 🫣

Translate

ABAMBO | Hard- and Software Engineer | Photographer

daniellei4510

Community Expert

Oh, there are still plenty of issues. But I do have a limited number of credits. 🙂

Translate

Adobe Community Expert | I have miles to go before I sleep, but I'm all done on this end.

Jill_C

Community Expert

The skin texture is unrealistic and there is haloing around some edges.

Translate

Jill C., Forum Volunteer

daniellei4510

Correct answer

Community Expert

Haloing and misshapen edges, noticeable even at this size. Slightly underexposed in the shadows.

Translate

Adobe Community Expert | I have miles to go before I sleep, but I'm all done on this end.

W

wilkasAuthor

Participant

Wow, are all these being found automatically? I haven't noticed misshapen edges until you showed me. These bright edges are what you call Haloing? I wonder if these are inherent to AI generated images and if I can easily fix them in post editing.

Translate

daniellei4510

Community Expert

Haloing can happen in AI images, but it can also happen when an asset is upscaled. There are YouTube videos on how to fix haloing. No, misshapen objects are not found automatically but by moderators. Always view your assets at a minimum of 100% after upscaling. 200% is even better. Sure, lots of issues can be addressed and corrected in Photoshop. It just depends on how much time you are willing to spend fixing things.

Translate

Adobe Community Expert | I have miles to go before I sleep, but I'm all done on this end.

yamato713108855

Community Expert

Is this the same size as the image you submitted?
Please upload the same image as you submitted.

Translate

W

wilkasAuthor

Participant

I did upload 9MB full resolution image, it might have been downscalled for preview

Translate

yamato713108855

Community Expert

Sorry, I checked.

As other community experts have mentioned, I'm concerned about the edges of the image being emphasized.
These lines can appear due to the algorithm and sharpening process used when enlarging an image.

Translate

Sign up

To post, reply, or follow discussions, please sign in with your Adobe ID.

Sign in to Adobe Community

To post, reply, or follow discussions, please sign in with your Adobe ID.