Skip to main content
mathiasrh
Known Participant
June 22, 2023
Question

Looking for input: Batch of 70 photos rejected because of quality issues

  • June 22, 2023
  • 4 replies
  • 3012 views

Hi community, 

I am uploading to Adobe Stock (and others) for about 6 years now and have a portfolio of roughly 5.000 images. Means I know my way around quidelines and so on. 

I am shooting with a Sony A1 and a Mavic 3 and try to produce very high quality photos in a very high resoltion. 

I was always happy with the moderation on Adobe side - until recently almost all my images get disapproved because of "Quality issues". Yesterday, a batch of 70 images was disapproved. That's very sad, because I consider some of them as my very best work. And they have been accepted on other platforms. 

I am attaching some examples as well as a overview screenshot of the images. 

Would be interested in your take on this!

This topic has been closed for replies.

4 replies

Nancy OShea
Community Expert
Community Expert
June 22, 2023

How many have you sold?  I ask because acceptance into Stock inventory is no guarantee of consistent sales activity. 

Stock inventory has exploded to over 300 million assets so they can afford to more choosy now -- as well they should.

 

As an unpaid forum volunteer, I haven't time to evaluate 10 images per person.  1-2 is the best you can hope for.

 

This image has two obvious mistakes which you should have identified yourself. 

1. The poorly focused foreground subject is distracting and sticks out like a sore thumb.  As a composition, it doesn't work.

2. Underexposed.  See histogram panel.

 

Examine your images at 100-300% magnification.  Make corrections if you can.  Discard the ones you can't fix.

Submit 5-6 of your highest quality images per batch. 

That should help reduce your rejection rate.

 

Hope that helps.  Good luck with your next submission.

 

Nancy O'Shea— Product User & Community Expert
mathiasrh
mathiasrhAuthor
Known Participant
June 22, 2023

Thank you so much. I absolutely appreciate the amount of time you have invested and your feedback. 

Yes, I actually do sell. In the last five years I das 18.000 downloads with about 20k EUR income what is great for me. 

About the issue posted: I am happy to share that all of the image, the complete rejected batch, is now online. Made a screenshot. 

Again, I appreciate all the input, that's very valuable!

mathiasrh
mathiasrhAuthor
Known Participant
June 22, 2023

Thanks for your feedback. I still don't think that those reasons where why the images were rejected.  I would like to let you know that Adobe Support has acknowledged that those images were rejected in error. Same as the last batch. 

My gut feeling is, that there is a lot of pressure on the content moderator due to the high amount of AI content. 

 

Here is the message from Adobe Support: 

Hello Mathias,

thank you very much for your message. The moderation team works independently and under its own management. Every day a lot of files are checked manually according to different parameters. Of course, errors can occur here from time to time.
This was certainly the case with a large number of your recent submissions.
I have now resent your files to the moderation team and assume that a weighty portion of your rejected files will be accepted.

Jill_C
Community Expert
Community Expert
June 22, 2023

Why did you post them here if you believe they will be accepted?

Jill C., Forum Volunteer
mathiasrh
mathiasrhAuthor
Known Participant
June 22, 2023

@Jill_C I don't understand the question. Isn't this what the community is for? Asking questions? Of course I did believe the images would be accepted. That's why I posted them here to understand if someone else is facing similar issues recently and / or has different opinions and explanations. 

Additionally, I reached out to contributer support to get more details. Especially because the flaws mentioned here result in a specific rejection reason (Focus, Exposure, etc) and not simply "Quality Issue"

Jill_C
Community Expert
Community Expert
June 22, 2023

Rejection-00005.jpg - underexposed in the shadows and there's a spot in the upper left corner that should be edited out.

Rejection-00001.jpg - lacks sharp focus and artifacts in the sky 

 

Jill C., Forum Volunteer
RALPH_L
Community Expert
Community Expert
June 22, 2023

0003- the foreground is distracting, the subject is not in focus, the shadows on the monument should be lightened.

0006- the subject is not in focus, the shadows on the volcanoes should be lightened, the sky is noisy (could be color noise) .

0007- the subject is not in focus, the shadows on the mountains should be lightened, the sky is noisy and has a magenta touch.

Overall, when viewing the other photos, I conclude focus, dark shadows and some noise is the problem. These can all be easily corrected in post processing.