Quality issues?

Forum|Forum|2 years ago
December 2, 2023
5 replies
1119 views

Hey everyone!

Any why did these get rejected for Quality issues?

Contributor critique

This topic has been closed for replies.

Correct answer Abambo

Beach: looks very fake. If you check the palms at 100%, you see forground melting into background.

Conference: besides the weird hand geometry, the whole picture is out of focus. Look also at the nose. seems to be pasted in. the jacket has a colour change, that I would have edited out.

Couple: @oleschwander nailed the most obvious error, that I saw immediately.

Indeed, your refusals are, what I would have expected at the beginning of the AI hype. A year ago those images would have passed.

Abambo

Correct answer

Community Expert

Beach: looks very fake. If you check the palms at 100%, you see forground melting into background.

Conference: besides the weird hand geometry, the whole picture is out of focus. Look also at the nose. seems to be pasted in. the jacket has a colour change, that I would have edited out.

Couple: @oleschwander nailed the most obvious error, that I saw immediately.

Indeed, your refusals are, what I would have expected at the beginning of the AI hype. A year ago those images would have passed.

ABAMBO | Hard- and Software Engineer | Photographer

Nancy OShea

Community Expert

Which AI service did you use to generate these?

Nancy O'Shea— Product User & Community Expert

B

Billijs23021023Author

Participant

Midjourney

Jill_C

Community Expert

The chin hair on the man in the first image is quite odd - looks more like fur; and as @daniellei4510 mentioned their eyes don't match, and catch lights are missing in one of his eyes.
In the third image, almost nothing is in focus, the hand is malformed, and it's odd that there would be an entire row of men all wearing the same suit and white shirt. I would definitely not label this as "realistic".

Jill C., Forum Volunteer

O

oleschwander

Legend

I would think it's this.

daniellei4510

Community Expert

Conference Room: Poorly formed hand on the man in the foreground.
Beach: At 200%, the palm trees becomer very "painterly" looking. If this was labeled as a Photo, it might have passed as an Illustration. Maybe.

The Couple. Look at their hair at 200%. Check out the woman's irises. They are different sizes. Catchlights should be idential on all four eyes as well.

Adobe Community Expert | If you can't fix it, hide it; if you can't hide it, delete it.