Skip to main content
Participating Frequently
December 9, 2022
Question

Questions on These Two

  • December 9, 2022
  • 3 replies
  • 371 views

Ok, I'm not completely sure why these were rejected. However, let me attempt some guesses. I'm intersted in your feedback.

 

* The Lilly. I'm thinking the f stop wasn't to the linking of the reviewer, however maybe there was too much noise reduction on the center of the lilly which maybe skewed away some focus?

 

* The drink, I'm thinking the bkg needs to be uniformly black minus the lights, and also have those distractions removed from the base of the glass? 

 

What do you guys suggest?

This topic has been closed for replies.

3 replies

Jill_C
Community Expert
Community Expert
December 9, 2022

The lily is just too soft - not only the center but some of the petals. I agree with @Ricky336 about the WB which could be warmed up a tad.

I like the drink image and wouldn't eliminate the bokeh effect of the lights in the background, but perhaps crop it a bit tighter to eliminate the reflection in the foreground on the wood table and the distracting elements on the right side. I feel like this one would pass with some minor tweaks (and a different Moderator).

Jill C., Forum Volunteer
Ricky336
Community Expert
Community Expert
December 9, 2022

Hello,

These are my suggestions:

Lilly - Alter the white balance. For me, it is just a bit too green/blue. Increase the tint and temp slider, reduce the highlights, and increase contrast and exposure. I personally don't think you need to increase the DoF.

The leaf directly behind the lotus flower though could be distracting. (?)

Glass - I would increase the exposure, decrease the highlights a bit more, and clone out the distracting lights; it gives a cleaner background! I see you've used f 5.6 this time. A better result than your previous glass picture. 

E.g:

 

 

 

 

Participating Frequently
December 9, 2022

Thank you for the thoughtful ideas! I appreciate the suggestions!

 

RALPH_L
Community Expert
Community Expert
December 9, 2022

The lilly has a dark halo around some of the pedals. Also the depth of field could have been deeper.

Participating Frequently
December 9, 2022

I don't think I could get a deeper fov without people bitching that something isn't in focus on this. However, I see what you're saying about the halo. I'll need to work on that. Awesome catch.