Skip to main content
Participant
October 19, 2017
Answered

Rejected Grain/Noise problem

  • October 19, 2017
  • 3 replies
  • 3896 views

Hi I had the following two images rejected because of a grain/noise problem, I've since upped the noise reduction a little, but wanted to get some feedback to if it's over processed as well, bad composition, whatever. Anything is appreciated!

This topic has been closed for replies.
Correct answer jacquelingphoto2017

It is very difficult avoiding digital noise, no matter the lighting. Sometimes it's more than others. To reduce the noise/grain on your photos a little post processing is required. Not much. Too much will take away the natural appearance, and/or introduce additional noise. One of the reasons for noise is your ISO setting. The higher the ISO the more noise introduced. It is recommended that you use the lowest ISO, however there are times (eg. late evening, or night) that you'll definitely require higher ISO settings. In this case you might require to adjust other settings that will allow the reduction of noise/grain. The best thing to do in this case is to get to know your camera. Read the manual and practice.

As I said before post processing is required in most cases, if not all. To inspect your photos for noise/grain, apply a 100 to 200% zoom. Look in the dark areas for digital noise, and in the smoother area for grains. Use the relevant noise reduction tool to reduce the chromatic and luminant  noise. Since this process softens your photos, sharpening is also required. Read up as much as you can on photo editing and practice. Some of your photos will eventually be accepted. You can start with Create better photos for Adobe Stock with 7 tips for success | I hope this helps.

Best wishes.

3 replies

duns12317219734
Known Participant
October 22, 2020

I had some photos rejected for technical problems yet one is much better lit & composed than others on here of the same subject. They didn't even say what was wrong, .I could find only CA color fringing in the below photo of the church but the others I can only guess. One below had a dark background maybe with a hand sanitizer bottle lit by colored spot lighting

Nancy OShea
Community Expert
Community Expert
October 22, 2020

Is there some reason you keep resurrecting 2 year old discussions?

Just saying...

 

 

 

Nancy O'Shea— Product User & Community Expert
duns12317219734
Known Participant
October 23, 2020

what does that mean?

joanH
Inspiring
May 24, 2018

It is never pleasant having your photographs or illustrations rejected. Hopefully, you have had enough of your work accepted and purchased to help you value your work as a professional photographer and you can handle this rejection process. It is not for the faint of heart.

May I suggest that there might be something to learn about these specific photographs. It is important for you and every other stock contributor to closely examine the photos at 100% magnification before you submit them to Adobe Stock. Until you have done this, nothing we say will make sense to you about your rejection for grain and noise problems. Look along all of the edges of objects. I can see some problems with the upper part of the wheel mostly on the right.

For now, this up to you to find the areas spotted by the source of the rejections. Once you get into the habit of being your own hard critic, you will know how to prepare your work for the Adobe Market.

It is also very important to learn and use all of the guidelines Adobe has published for all stock contributors. If you do want to sell through Adobe Stock you will want to memorize these guidelines and strictly adhere to them. Here is a site for you to visit. I hope you will not give up but it is up to you. Best regards, JH

For  you to be able to achieve better image results and get offerings accepted into Adobe Stock go to   https://helpx.adobe.com/stock/contributor/user-guide.html

Participant
January 24, 2020

Image noise / grain isn't just created by the ISO & camera but also by lack of light. I had images rejected on here & other sites at 200 - 800 ISO because of noise.  It wasn't the cameras fault, (sony alpha Nex 5n} just that it was taken just after sundown when the sky is getting darker. I reduced the noise on GIMP software which is free and they should be fine.hopefuly

When the sky was almost completely dark, I had a photo accepted on here even at 1600 ISO 

davids77975692
Participant
January 8, 2018

I'm not sure what's going on with all these rejections because of noise/grain. It's clearly an algorithm analyzing all the images and making a bad judgement call. Can someone at Adobe please get to the bottom of this? All of my images are rejected for noise grain problems. Non processed, exterior daylight, properly exposed images get rejected for noise.

Sherwood_Martinelli
Known Participant
March 11, 2018

I feel your pain...I had 46 out of 55-60 pictures rejected tonight, ALL OF THEM for Grain/Noise issues.   The other big generic one that gets A LOT OF ACTION is Artifact Issues...not saying I am the best photographer in the world (not even close) but seems rather odd that 3 out of 4 of my submissions are rejected, the over-whelming majority of them for Grain/Noise or Artifact issues...so tonight, I carefully scrutinized by rejections...IN ONE MINUTE someone from Adobe rejected 11 of my images for Grain/Noise issues.  46 images rejected in a period of about two hours.

First, cannot believe a HUMAN is actually looking at 60 of my pictures in a matter of less than two hours.  Furthermore, I agree with you that their Algorithms may be off.

Keep plugging away...to hit my goal of 4000 accepted images I only have to submit about 16,000 more to hit my goal at the current rate of rejection.

Sherwood

Inspiring
May 24, 2018

I also had several images rejected for grain/noise and I have decided that Adobe Stock is a complete waste of time. You'll never earn anything to compensate for all of the time spent shooting at the rate things get rejected.