Skip to main content
Participant
February 13, 2025
Question

What exactly is wrong, why are these png format illustrations not accepted?

Maybe someone can tell me what's wrong with these Illustrations and why they are not accepted into stock (they say it's a quality issue)

4 replies

Abambo
Community Expert
Community Expert
February 13, 2025

Let's first check your cut-out:

It's exceptionally clean, but still contains errors like these ones:

The blue points out to areas that are at the border of a transparency. So inside of the full material, you have islands of tranparent pixels. That will greatly annoy a possible buyer when they put it against 

I also think that thge cutout circle is not correct, and that the cutout should be smoother. 

 

Second, you have rendering errors like these ones a little bit every where:

Third, there are inconsistant sharpness levels in your file. That too will be highly annoying to a buyer, as this is visible even when the asset is not shown full size:

 

I didn't check the other assets, but I suppose they are all the same with more or less similar errors. 

 

In conclusion: assets like this are easy to model in a 3D program, and you really should avoid doing this in generative AI, because generative AI obviously still has no clue what they are rendering.

Translate
ABAMBO | Hard- and Software Engineer | Photographer
photorebelle
Inspiring
February 13, 2025

Do your illustrations have a transparent background? Because PNG is reserved for transparent backgrounds

Translate
Abambo
Community Expert
Community Expert
February 13, 2025
quote

Do your illustrations have a transparent background? Because PNG is reserved for transparent backgrounds


By @photorebelle

For all you could say about these assets, they have a good but not perfect alpha channel.

Translate
ABAMBO | Hard- and Software Engineer | Photographer
Jill_C
Community Expert
Community Expert
February 13, 2025

Some inconsistencies in the drawing:

Translate
Jill C., Forum Volunteer