Elements in component states jump around in prototype

In the editor, my component looks just as I'd expect. 

In preview and posted prototypes, the elements in the component jump around between states.

I started out with a nested component to get the menu I needed but simplified things to try and make things easier on XD. I've been banging my head against the wall on this for close to an hour, trying every variation I can think of. Nothing seems to make a difference. 

This is the second time I've hit this behavior with XD in the last week. For the last one, I just gave up and created an old school static representation of each state for my team. Cutting edge.

Here's the states in design mode. Gif compression wiped out most of the differences, but you get the idea. The "more" button is not part of the component.

And here's how it behaves in Preview mode and shared prototypes.