Skip to main content
Andrew Yoole
Inspiring
August 31, 2009
Question

AFTER EFFECTS WISHLIST

  • August 31, 2009
  • 202 replies
  • 212566 views

What features would you like to see implemented in After Effects? New ideas for plugins? Interface changes? Post 'em here!

Let's keep bug identification to individual posts, as these will probably be addressed more readily. Let's use this thread for specific ideas about ways that AE can be improved and expanded.

These Forums are for users, not Adobe employees, so don't forget to also fill in an Adobe feature request form.

To view the Wish List posts prior to September 2009, look here.

    202 replies

    Sterphy
    Known Participant
    October 11, 2025

    I hate the way AE handles 3D.  Like how when you click to make a layer 3D and it will jump somewhere else in the comp because it isn't aligned to the current view.  Everything 3D is just so BAD - I'd like to see them overhaul the 3d workspace completely and make it more logical.  Timeline folders.  It's insane that we still don't have them, and disk preview instead of RAM preview - NVME are plenty fast enough that previews can just be rendered to the disk temporarily 

    Awesome_determination0D4D
    Known Participant
    September 18, 2023

    I wish multiple clips could be place on the same layer. As of now you can only place 1 clip on a single layer. I wish it was like PPro.

    Thank God, if we wish to loop a clip we can loop it in its property. However if I wanted a set of 2 clips of one kind and 1 other another kind loop several times. My comp woyuld grow vertically as well as horizontally. Severe real estate wastage and bad ergonomics.

     

    https://www.santanu.biz

    Awesome_determination0D4D
    Known Participant
    March 31, 2020

    A simple wish, difficult to implement for commercial reasons - Allow multiple clips in the same layer. Period. AE will replace PP. Allow PP style transitions in AE. You won't need PP any more. Sound's like an atomic bomb?

     

    www.santanu.biz

    nubnubbud
    Inspiring
    September 30, 2022

    a new after effects. made from the ground up to support modern hardware, not 1999 single core no gpu computers, but actual workstations with dedicated graphics hardware, either on or off-die. also maybe real multithreading and not just using different threads to render different frames separately. also making the built in effects 16 or 32 bit. also having a proper 3D view and not 2.5D.
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aVNCgmAsI8c&t=1166s

    Participant
    November 26, 2019

    1/ Allow camera Point Of Interest to have Seperate Dimensions (PLEASE!!!)

    2/ Be able to lock Focus Distance to Point Of Interest
    3/ To be able to lock Focal Distance and/or Point of Interest to an object or null

    michaeld15147761
    Inspiring
    April 10, 2017

    This may have been listed here already, but what about a way to extend all nested comps to match the length of the parent comp? There's already a 3rd party script for this (rd: Comp Setter - aescripts + aeplugins - aescripts.com ) but having it built in would be nice. There could be a checkbox to have all nested comps extended/trimmed in the Composition Settings dialogue box. Maybe any layer in the nested comps that goes until the end of that comp's timeline would automatically be extended as well (perhaps via a secondary checkbox)?

    mave1969
    Known Participant
    April 10, 2017

    For the love of all that's holy I wish AE was even partway intelligent about locating missing footage. In other Adobe apps like InDesign, finding one missing asset automatically leads to the app locating any other missing files in the same folder, or even in the same relative folder structure. AE is dreadful at this. The number of times I end up having to manually re-link a whole bunch of images in the same folder is just maddening.

    Szalam
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    April 12, 2017

    My AE behaves the way you are wishing for. I relinked one thing and had it find 49 others by itself just the other day.

    I would be frustrated as heck if it hadn't done that.

    I wonder why yours isn't behaving. The assets involved wouldn't happen to be JPEG sequences or JPEGs, would they?

    mave1969
    Known Participant
    May 6, 2017

    They were JPGs and now I see why. Hopefully the fix in 14.2 will solve things.

    genvfx
    Known Participant
    January 30, 2017

    I would really like to if there was a way to have a layer override so that you could preview at, say, a quarter res, but have an override that makes one layer, for example a safe overlay image from a client, at full res so you can completely make out the edges.

    It sounds simple in my head, but I'm sure it'll be a nightmare

    G

    Inspiring
    February 8, 2017

    You could work in 1/4 res and in comp settings, make sure "Preserve Resolution When Nested". Then put that precomp into your logo comp that's full res. You'd see the logo at full res and the pre comp at 1/4 res at the same time. You'd still need to step into your pre comp to make changes, so it's not entirely what you are asking.

    Maybe this would be easier to implement: a variable opacity full-res guide layer similar to Show Snapshot? But have Show Snapshot persistent or toggle on/off (Instead of a momentary button like it is now)?

    genvfx
    Known Participant
    February 17, 2017

    Hi Navarro

    Yes, that does work, but , as you say, it's a kind of reviewing comp and that's inefficient when it comes to making edits.

    What I would really like is a small toggle button next to the Cont. Rasterize.  Maybe instead of the shy button, that allows for Full/half/quarter res for reviewing work - Showing F/H/Q with a colour change making it obvious which override is on.  A global button for toggling it on and off like they have for Blur.

    I know, it'll never happen, but this is a Wishlist

    G

    Participating Frequently
    December 18, 2016

    Ability to add 3d layers to be a true 3d space precomp

    Like when 2 or more 3d layers are precompd together you have an option for true 3d space

    prowl
    Known Participant
    December 18, 2016

    So... just goign tofire these off here again... I know that we need to use the request link.

    Feature Request/Bug Report Form

    But need to actually get people to put in more requests

    3D Space

    Make it more like a 3d Application. It's all very forced 2D now

    3D Connection Support

    Interface

    Goddamn easy Keyboard shortcut customisation on windows!  it's 2016! 

    Kill all the Modal pop ups - like the comp settings.  Make it a panel so you can change it on the fly or be able to select multiple comps and change them.

    Same for any other modal pops - lights / cameras / Solids / placeholder - All of them! Make them panels!

    Inspiring
    September 18, 2016

    3 features that may or may not already exist that I'd like to exist:

    (please do tell me if it already exists)

    When making shape layers, rather than using only merge paths implements - how about an actual mask tool within shape groups?

    Or a stencil alpha in the compositing effects dropdown-> then a black shape could act as a clipping mask within a shape layer group

    OR within merge paths add a  'path only' option/section that ignores fill values?

    usage: for complex shapes where merge paths has undesirable effects.

    Grouping layers within comps as has been already suggested

    A 'thisGroup' type code for expressions.

    Usage example:

    Random moustache generator
    Expression control slider  number (1-5)

    5 moustache shapes named 1,2,3,4 & 5

    • on slider:
      • seedRandom(0,1);
      • random(1,5);
    • on each moustache groups transparency
      • if(thisGroup.name == effect(moustache number)) 100 else 0;

    Easy to then duplicate moustache layers and add more types without modifying code each time

    Participating Frequently
    October 26, 2016

    So we were still using CS6 until recently... I know we may have been the last people in the country to get up to date, but we're finally current.  The playback in After Effects has been driving me crazy ever since and I was wondering if there were any workarounds or discussion about why they made certain changes...

    Problem 1:  I hit RAM Preview, I leave After Effects to do something else on my computer, sometimes that thing involves sound... then a minute or three later After Effects finishes previewing and just starts playing audio from that comp, whether I'm actually in AFX or am in something else like Chrome or what have you.  This drives me crazy, is there any way to get it to finish its preview but have it wait for me to return to just start playing?

    Problem 2:  I set in and out points for some portion of my comp, then I preview it... it's not a terribly heavy comp so it previews pretty quickly, but it either plays slowed down audio, or no audio if I set it that way, until it's ready to play in real time.  But, by the time it's ready to play in real time it's 2 or 3 or however many seconds into playback.  So now I've missed the beginning of what I'm trying to view, and have to wait until it gets to the end and starts over.  Sometimes that's 2 seconds, sometimes it's 20 or 30 or more.

    So my two issues that I'd like to see options or fixes for (and please do tell me if I'm missing some settings somewhere), would be that RAM Preview waits for you to come back to AFX before just playing when it finishes, and that playback doesn't begin until it's ready to actually play the whole thing - basically, like it used to be.

    Thanks for looking.