Skip to main content
Andrew Yoole
Inspiring
August 31, 2009
Question

AFTER EFFECTS WISHLIST

  • August 31, 2009
  • 203 replies
  • 212715 views

What features would you like to see implemented in After Effects? New ideas for plugins? Interface changes? Post 'em here!

Let's keep bug identification to individual posts, as these will probably be addressed more readily. Let's use this thread for specific ideas about ways that AE can be improved and expanded.

These Forums are for users, not Adobe employees, so don't forget to also fill in an Adobe feature request form.

To view the Wish List posts prior to September 2009, look here.

    203 replies

    Leonardo Sulzbach
    Participant
    October 27, 2014

    Creation of infinite labels, mask point information output to be useful in some animation stuff... thanks!!

    Participant
    September 8, 2014

    I would like the maximum mask expansion size to be increased from +/-1000, to +/-4000 or more. Animating mask expansions can be used for things like ink bleeds in combination with the Roughen Edges effect, which requires you to be able to have the expanded mask cover the whole frame, even if it starts out at one edge.  Limiting it to +/-1000 pixels doesn't allow you to encompass the whole frame when working with 4K video, if the original mask shape is off to one edge.

    A workaround would be to just animate the mask path, but it's easier to just set two keyframes for the expansion, instead of manually scaling up the mask.

    ofek.dan
    Participating Frequently
    July 8, 2014
    • Right-To-Left writing support.
    • Better ways to zoom with Magic Mouse and Magic Trackpad (pinch-to-zoom?)
    the_dudes
    Inspiring
    July 8, 2014

    Wheel zoom directing to mouse cursor. I know about the alt-zoom, but I want the option to set it to default in the prefs.

    Participating Frequently
    June 11, 2014

    Two features that would save me minutes a day, hours a month, and days a year in time.

    Background Auto-save [it currently does auto-save in the foreground]

    Display ALL offline fonts. Limiting the list of offline fonts to three is a nuisance, If i get a hand me down project I want to know all the fonts I need to activate, not just the first three.

    PLEASE ADOBE!!

    Participating Frequently
    June 25, 2014

    Two features that would save me minutes a day, hours a month, and days a year in time.

    Background Auto-save [it currently does auto-save in the foreground]

    Display ALL offline fonts. Limiting the list of offline fonts to three is a nuisance, If i get a hand me down project I want to know all the fonts I need to activate, not just the first three.

    PLEASE ADOBE!!

    Really unimpressed with the new features added to AE... good thing I subscribe to the latest updates... maybe they will improve AE for CC 2015

    prowl
    Known Participant
    May 29, 2014

    I've got one that doesn't seem to get mentioned.

    Multiple projects in tabs... as per Photoshop / illustrator etc.

    The ability to open up more than one project at a time and just copy and paste comps / layers effects without having to import a whole AEP into a project.  

    Quantum Catnip
    Participant
    May 23, 2014

    I do first person shooter, video based, video games.  So that means lots of really long POV shots.  I would like to use the Warp Stabilizer tool on these shots but they are unmanageably long shots and sometimes have entire crowds of people running through them.  So there are obvious sections where I can NOT use the stabilizer successfully.  I get that.  So I end up breaking my shot up and using the Stabilizer on just sections of the shot.  PROBLEM: How do I TRANSITION from a section that IS stabilized in or out from a section that is NOT stabilized?  OPTION ONE: I keyframe scale, rotation and position in order to get as close as possible to minimize the jump.  The drawback of this approach is that I still can't make up for the subspace warp effect and will therefore have a jump in my image no matter what (yes, I could try to use the mesh warp).  Very time consuming and not very satisfactory.  OPTION TWO:  I stair step my stabilized layer for each frame and change the stabilization value on each frame so that I create a frame by frame ramp of the stabilization effect.

    SOLUTION SUGGESTION:  Can we get a value added to the Warp Stabilizer that allows us to keyframe the effect in and out?  Can that allow us to confine the effect to only a section of a clip so that the entire clip does not get processed?  That would be very useful and problem solving for me.  i.e.- I only want to use the Warp Stabilizer on a single portion of clip or on several individual portions of a clip.

    P.S.- Come to think of it, this could be really helpful on the 3D Camera Tracker as well... only having to track a portion and solve the camera for a portion of a clip allows me to target the actual section where I'm planning on putting in the effect.  It also would save me the computation time for sections I won't even be needing tracked or stabilized or whatever.

    PFuerst
    Inspiring
    May 13, 2014

    Lately I was thinking about what bothers me the most while working in AFX and came to the conclusion that I really don't like to alter settings in the timeline. IF you have just a few layers it is ok but as soon as the layer count goes up I find myself constantly shifting my layout around which stops me from being creative and rises my frustration level– also all the shortcuts to maximize the panel or unveiling specific attributes doesn't help to much when you want to change roatation sacle and opavity for example on 20layers at once. I would rather have a special panel next to the timeline, showing all the attributes(scale, opacity,... essentially making the transform effect a panel which controls the layers) as soon as a layer is selected. Much like the attribute panel in C4d which is also really helpful when changing the same settings for more than 1 layer. The timeline could then be used to just to shift keyframes around and act more like a dope sheet.

    Of course this would change the way we work with AFX a lot but I think for the better. I have also filed a feature request for it (with a lot more smaller suggestions) but thought that I also post it here as some of you might want think about it and also file a feature request report for it so that the AFX team sees that it is something to think through and maybe integrate.

    As I started using C4d more and more I noticed a lot of those small but effective workflow tools which I think AFX users could also benefit from but this one was the most important one I guess.

    PFuerst
    Inspiring
    July 7, 2014

    I've made a quick mock up to show how this might work/look like

    donbarrum
    Inspiring
    March 26, 2014

    Some things I would like:

    1! . I would love to see after effects using multiple cores while you are working not just in rendering. An optimized After Effects for newer machines would be greatly appreciated by many. I think After effects has a ton of great features all ready, IMO its time to put effort into optimization and the use of GPU and all CPU cores of modern systems all across the program.

    2. Folders and other things that can make it easier to have an overview of complex large comps. I mean Folders/groups in the comp view and better layer color system.

    Community Expert
    March 26, 2014

    On your first point, a frame of video is only as big as the frame. The power of processors and the availability of ram have far exceeded the system requirements for a frame of video. Any codec or 3rd party plug-in that is not fully MP aware will kill the MP process so this inefficiency is not all on Adobe's shoulders.

    A 3D app can more easily utilize all system resources because 3D rendering is just math and you can stack up and multi thread math operations as much as you would like. Rendering 3D objects, calculating polygons and light rays is completely different than looking at all of the pixels in an HD frame and running calculations on that frame until the calculations are done so you can move on to the next frame. MP for AE is a good idea, there's just too many pieces of the puzzle that are not created by Adobe to make it work yet...

    donbarrum
    Inspiring
    March 26, 2014

    I do not understand the complexity of it all. But as far as I understand, a lot of what AE is doing while you are working, is much similar to what f.example Final Cut does, only you have more freedom and a 2.5D scene. but blurring an image, filters and whatnot is also possible through programs such as Final Cut, and in that program and with an MP you can get extreme performance. Even on my iMac the performance in Final Cut is obviously a lot better than in After Effects, even for the simplest tasks such as playing a movie with no effects (I can even do Keying in realtime in final cut, while in AE it take a lot of time)
    AE is slow after a couple of layers of particles or similar things....which feels kinda out-of date. Especially if all but 1 core is still idling on your machine while you are working. So it would make sense to me if adobe would optimize AE to exploit todays machines, put as much as possibled over on the GPU and use multiple cores whenever possible. But that´s coming from someone who doesn´t understand the complex math behind it all - I just see what other softwares do in comparison.

    Participant
    February 15, 2014

    I would love some color correction tools that operate in a similar fashion to the UI in Lightroom - sliders and tool panels. I dislike color wheels. Thanks!

    Bob Currier
    Participating Frequently
    February 15, 2014

    You may want to check out Color Finesse, which is included with After Effects CC as well as versions as far back as AE 7.0.

    It has lots (and lots) of sliders to control all aspects of color correction, as well as curves and, yes, color wheels (which you can ignore). There is the "simplified UI" which appears in the regular ECW, but click the "Full UI" button to get full access to all controls.

    Bob Currier

    Synthetic Aperture

    genvfx
    Known Participant
    March 6, 2014

    Hi there,

    I would love there to be a way to animate whether motion blur is on or not during a comp, especially when you have a long shot that only requires some frames to be blurred, for example when a fast move occurs in the middle.

    It really slows down a comp when the motion blur os on for all frames.

    Also, being able to animate the shutter angle and samples too of the comp, that would be good.