An intended workflow for videography with animation
We are a small design studio, often working on projects that use Premiere Pro and After Effects in tandem to create video projects that include overlayed animations and motion graphics. The obvious question that I'm leading up to is: What is the best workflow for this kind of project?
I know it's very specific to our situation. My partner works with filming and editing to create video (PP), and I take the video and animate over it, creating custom animations (AE). We work on seperate computers and unconnected drives. There is almost always a need for passing back-and-forth projects, between us and the client, and between video and animation, to get a project out the door. The most uncomplicated and fool-proof method we've found so far is to export an MP4 video, animate over it, and export the animations with an alpha channel, again flattened, and send back for video editing, etc.. No matter which direction we work though, it often needs to go back and forth, and one of us needs to work on a flattened file, not having access to the layers, compositions/sequences of the other. This means tiny, 1-or-2 frame edits in the video require several exports and hand-overs to be corrected.
We've tried dynamic linking, and found it only barely better, if at all. One big flaw we find is that it seems that any workflow between PP and AE seems to require one of both workers to be proficient with both AE and PP, since the dynamic links don't really seem to be two-directional. It seems crazy that the workflow would require an individual to be both a videographer and an animator, though, in software knowledge at least. The programs also operate much slower with dynamic links, effects often have errors between programs, and overall, the transitions back and forth doesn't seem faster or less complicated. We often pass an external harddrive back and forth between computers, collecting and packaging projects each time we go back and forth, which can take several hours. We just can't shake the feeling that we're doing this all wrong, and all the videos and forum posts online don't seems to make things easier.
We're kind of wondering: In similar circumstances, is there an intended workflow for this kind of project? Is it best to work AE to PP with dynamic files, or PP to AE? If only one way is optimal, then which program should be doing color correcting and warp stabalization, and at what point in the process?
I realize how complex this question is, and I know there are numerous forum posts on the topic, it's just that most seem directed at one person working on one drive with both programs.
