Can't find a "regular" style for my font

I'm trying to get the "regular" style for my font (source sans pro) for my text, but it won't show in the options in AE. I have all the rest, (extralight, light, italics, bold, etc) accessible to me

I'm on a mac.

I have the font successfully installed in Fontbook.

It is turned on in Typekit.

The regular font shows up in Illustrator.

I have uninstalled and reinstalled the program/app.

I can't seem to find an answer as to why "Regular" won't show up as an option in After Effects. Any advice and help would be greatly appreciated