Colors wrong after export

Every time I create a new project, I have to disable the "Use color display management" because it changes my colors like in the image below. (the preview is what I want it to look like)

However, if I forget and turn it off in the middle of the project, I cant really return my colors to what it would look like with the option checked. So when I render out it just kind of ruins the colors. My color spaces match in the project settings and export, but it still comes out different.

Is there a way to get AE to render as it would look like in the preview? As if  "Use color display management" was in the render as well? 
And no. The video player does not matter here. It's the same no matter if i put it in potplayer, premiere, etc.