Linked AE comp in Premiere not updating.

I export a sequence from Premiere Pro using "Replace with After Effects Composition".  I create 3D title in AE, save, and go back to the Premiere Sequence.  The title is there in the sequence, but I want to change the text.  I select the Linked Comp in the Project panel and click match frame.  I type  the new letters in the Effect Controls AE Editable Text panel and that is fine, it changes the letters. However it is not keeping the text parameters I selected in After Effects.

For example I had ALL CAPS in AE and Acumin font. When I change the title in the Linked Comp in Premiere it doesn't make all caps and it is a different font.  What am I doing wrong?

I am running Premiere Pro CC 13.0.2 and AE CC 16.0.1 on an iMac High Sierra. Thank you.