Shinny refractor in after effects

I don't see the modes column and it does not look like you are using the Add or Screen blend mode anywhere in your comp.

Turn on both of the first two icons at the bottom left corner of the timeline panel so we can see both the switches and modes column for your layers then drag the screenshot to the reply field and not the Drag and Drop here area so we can see what you have done.

To fake it:

I'd start with a shape layer gradient with opacity on each end and add a single line stroke with gaussian blur, then fiddle with some blend modes and animate everything. Starting with a screenshot of the effect without reflections this took a couple of minutes.

If you want a real reflective environment you'll have to make the card layer 3D, the environment layer 2D (probably a pre-comp) then enable the Cinema 4D rendering option and fiddle with the material options (aa) of the 3D card layer and the position of lights. You'll also have to live with the render times. 

The other option is to use a 3rd Party 3D app like Element 3D from Video Copilot.

This was probably done in a 3d program, but if you look up Environment Layers, you can totally replicate this kind of thing directly in After Effects with the native tools.