Arms Are Not Recording Where I place them

So I made my puppet, and tried a simple animation of them holding a game controller and moving a bit. I posed the arms so they're be bent and holding the Controller like she's playing it, did my recording and it looked fine. However, when I exported it, the arms were in WILDLY different poses than what I recorded them as, being bent like she was shrugging.

What am I doing wrong as far as moving the arms for recording?