Skip to main content
Inspiring
January 15, 2018
Answered

Problem with Marquee Text selection

  • January 15, 2018
  • 9 replies
  • 2496 views

I have seen other questions for this and none of them have sufficient answers. With the 2018 update, I now have alot of trouble with text selection.

If I were to take a stab at specifying the case, here it is.  When I am editing text and I have a text box in scope, I am accustomed to being able to easily marquee select text for highlighting / editing (in 2017 and prior). Now, with 2018, it often creates a NEW text element when I try to marquee select text I am editing. I believe that in the past, I could start a Marquee selection with my mouse outside the bounds of the text box. But in 2018, that will now create a new text box. So I must be extremely precise with the marquee selection start point, at Illustrator is very finicky about it. In fact it requires not only that I be within the the text box - but that my cursor is actually over text IN the box at the time the marquee selection starts. This is very limiting, as it is virtually impossible to group select the exact text you want as you only have about a pixel or two beyond the last character before the cursor is considered out of scope.

Looks like alot of other people have had this problem, and yes I have tried checking Preferences-> Type and "type Objection Selection by Path Only" is not checked. And checking it makes it even harder to select text.

Thank you.

    This topic has been closed for replies.
    Correct answer anthonyf17501227

    Your post was worth much to me as was trying to do this in CC2015 over and over, until I realized this only worked in CC2017.

    Looking at this all now, would agree with the original poster as  I preferred how this worked in 2017. So if you post  link to your bug ticket you'll get  my vote on this.


    Thanks Mike, Here is a link to the bug/feature request ticket.

    Enable 2017 functionality of marquee selecting text without exiting text tool – Adobe Illustrator Feedback

    9 replies

    Inspiring
    February 1, 2018

    This issue is driving me CRAZY.   I work with text all day. I almost want to go back to cc2017.   I even seen Twitch (Creative) streams where the artist is accidently making new text boxes consistantly.   I point it out but nobody seems to care.  

    Inspiring
    January 16, 2018

    Ah thanks for the context. To that end, the Designers can probably come up with a rule set where it makes a new box when clicking out ( on click release) but not when marquee selecting existing text after releasing.

    Although outside of that Id still make the feature request to revert to old functionality as a Preference checkbox, because clicking out to exit and select another object was very handy, and clicking out to make a new text element seems only contextually useful to a limited set of tasks such asmaking a bunch of quick labels or something at once. Not as good for focusing on one object or switching between text objects and other types of objects.

    i Already made a bug ticket, do I need to re-do it?

    Inspiring
    January 16, 2018

    Thank you all for the responses. Reminder that we are not there yet and have in fact just clarified the issue a bit further.

    Regarding Monika Gause's response, it is true that you can't marquee select text in an unselected text element.

    However, the issue here as I just verified on 2017 is that when the text element is already in scope, you COULD marquee select from out of its bounds in 2017 and before. In 2018, you cannot and it will create a new text element.

    The issue may be more specific, its hard to know without 2 computers side by side. But as of now that seems pretty specific to be added to a buglist.

    Monika Gause
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    January 16, 2018

    However, the issue here as I just verified on 2017 is that when the text element is already in scope, you COULD marquee select from out of its bounds in 2017 and before. In 2018, you cannot and it will create a new text element.

    That change has been made on purpose, so it's not a bug in the sense of the word.

    A lot of people were annoyed by the fact that before creating a new textbox you first had to deselect the active one. And that has been changed. So you need to make a feature request, not a bug report.

    Mike_Gondek10189183
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    January 15, 2018

    Hi Anthony,

    I do not remember ever being able to click and drag outside a text container without that creating a  new text container.

    But try turning this off just incase that helps.

    I do prefer the  illustrator before shapes as I cannot make type changes from farther away unless i Zoom in because nearby elements keep getting their corners rounded. All I want to do is update our job slug date and version number, on all the files I have open, but now  take sponger as I have to zoom in for each type edit.

    jane-e
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    January 15, 2018

    anthonyf17501227  wrote

    When I am editing text and I have a text box in scope, I am accustomed to being able to easily marquee select text for highlighting / editing (in 2017 and prior). Now, with 2018, it often creates a NEW text element when I try to marquee select text I am editing.

    Which tool are you using when you are marquee selecting the text and are you using any modifier keys?

    Inspiring
    January 15, 2018

    Thanks Monika. I would need to be able to run CC2017 to confirm EXACTLY what the difference is. I'm flying a little blind there. Certainly I know that I use Illustrator weekly for years and as soon as 2018 hit I am running into this problem constantly, and it is a new problem for me. I will check some of my other computers when I get home if they let me run without updating.

    Inspiring
    January 15, 2018

    Thank you Krishunt. How do I file a bug report? A quick search on the topic didn't yield me much except for moderators sometimes saying they will file it by commenting here.

    Kris Hunt
    Legend
    January 15, 2018
    Kris Hunt
    Legend
    January 15, 2018

    All you can do is file a bug report.

    Monika Gause
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    January 15, 2018

    When you want to edit text with the text tool, you can't start the click and drag outside the text box.

    Kris Hunt
    Legend
    January 15, 2018

    > When you want to edit text with the text tool, you can't start the click and drag outside the text box.

    You could in Illustrator 2017.

    Monika Gause
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    January 15, 2018

    KrisHunt  schrieb

    > When you want to edit text with the text tool, you can't start the click and drag outside the text box.

    You could in Illustrator 2017.

    I can't in CC2017

    neither in CC2015