Skip to main content
joshualangman
Participating Frequently
Jun 6, 2025 9:57 PM UTC
Question

Bizarre bug: dynamic footnote jumps to middle of text frame

Please see screenshot.

 

What I did: I applied a paragraph style containing "split column" options to some text.

What happened: one of the several dynamic footnotes in the text frame jumped to above the multicolumn text. Only the note whose reference occurs before the multicolumn text moved.

What now: I am stuck with a renegade footnote in the middle of the text flow, separated from the other notes at the bottom. I can't get it to rejoin its friends.

What I wished had happened: Not this. Footnotes should stay at the foot of the page.

 

Thanks for any help.

 

Josh

16 replies

Willi Adelberger
Community Expert
Community Expert
Jun 10, 2025 6:02 PM UTC

That is not a bug. Always when a different span column setting is applied, previous footnotes are above this paragraph. That is how it was designed. 

Translate
joshualangman
Participating Frequently
Jun 10, 2025 6:25 PM UTC

Hi WIlli.

 

If I may be so bold: why? Why was this choice made? Who wanted this behavior? It makes no sense to me, and apparently not to other book designers either.

 

If this is the desired behavior, shouldn't it have relevant settings in the document footnote settings dialog? There is nothing there about it.

 

Thanks,

Josh

Translate
Peter Kahrel
Community Expert
Community Expert
Jun 7, 2025 12:16 PM UTC

An old sore. Adobe insist it was designed that way, it's not a bug. Poor design you'll say, but there you are. If tou want it changed, join the crowds at https://indesign.uservoice.com

Translate
joshualangman
Participating Frequently
Jun 7, 2025 12:55 PM UTC

Hi, Peter! Good to see your name here. (Not sure if you remember, but you wrote some scripts for me many years ago.)

 

How could this possibly not be a bug? Is this a known issue? I wasn't seeing anything specifically about it at Uservoice, but I did file a bug report.

Translate
Peter Kahrel
Community Expert
Community Expert
Jun 7, 2025 1:48 PM UTC

Hi Joshua. Yes, I do remember -- TextBank!

 

It is a known issue and was discussed at length some years ago with Adobe engineers but they decided that this was the way it was. It was then suggested to them that what non-engineers (people like you and me) thought should be the expected behaviour should at least be added as an alternative, but it didn't happen.

Translate
Community Expert
Jun 7, 2025 11:56 AM UTC

Hi @joshualangman ,

please supply an InDesign document where this happens.

Could be dummy text, if you do not want to share the original content.

 

Thanks,
Uwe Laubender
( Adobe Community Expert )

Translate
joshualangman
Participating Frequently
Jun 7, 2025 12:52 PM UTC

Third page of this document.

Translate
joshualangman
Participating Frequently
Jun 8, 2025 12:40 AM UTC

Hi Uwe,

 

Thanks for looking into this. Can you confirm that this is a bug?

 

Josh

Translate