Skip to main content
Participant
December 5, 2024
Answered

Multiple mp3's on an InDesign page?

  • December 5, 2024
  • 2 replies
  • 360 views

I use InDesign 5.5. I created a page, placed five mp3 songs on it, exported the page as PDF. Got a file whose size indicates that the audio files are all embedded. Yay!

If I open the PDF in Acrobat Reader, clicking on the preview starts every song correctly. That's great, but clicking again, or clicking another song doesn't stop the old song from continuing. Oops! Once started, a MP3 plays to the very end no matter what I do short of closing Reader. If a user clicks several MP3's they all play resulting in a major sonic cacophony... hmm.

Is there an elegant solution to having a handful of songs on a book page? Thank you.

Correct answer BobLevine

Best advice I can give you is to give this up. You'll never get an acceptable result with multimedia in a PDF. This is especially true using a 13 year old version of InDesign which will probably let you do a bunch of things that aren't even supported anymore.

2 replies

Participant
January 14, 2025

Original poster here... here is the final result: a free PDF book about Puna, Hawaii with 12 Easter Egg songs: https://tinyurl.com/3kpbufj5 It's 300 Megs, because it has 250 color pictures too. You're correct, for the music to work right, Acrobat Reader is needed, the web browsers don't always play along. Now I just have to figure out the best way to hand this first book of mine out free, as Amazon would charge me $1 for every $0 "sale"... hmm.

BobLevine
Community Expert
BobLevineCommunity ExpertCorrect answer
Community Expert
December 5, 2024

Best advice I can give you is to give this up. You'll never get an acceptable result with multimedia in a PDF. This is especially true using a 13 year old version of InDesign which will probably let you do a bunch of things that aren't even supported anymore.

Participant
December 6, 2024

Today I field tested the same file at a Net Cafe, and everything worked. Start and stop buttons did appear for every mp3 and functioned perfectly. 

So the issue is only with the 32-bit Reader (24.004.20272) that I have on my own trusty Windows 7 laptop. I ran an update to the latest 24.005.20307 - still the same behavior. I went to Adobe and tried to download a 64-bit Reader, but its installer wanted to nuke my trusty ole Acrobat Pro 8 that I use daily. "No way, Jose."

I guess I'll just put only one mp3 song per page, and spread them out far from each other in the book so by the time the reader finds the next mp3, the previous one finished playing.  These songs are freebies anyway, if they work for the user, they work, if they don't, they don't...

leo.r
Community Expert
Community Expert
December 6, 2024

your users can view the file in countless different PDF readers, including browser-based, in each of which the behavior will be unpredictable.