Skip to main content
Inspiring
May 7, 2025
Question

Package and sharing

  • May 7, 2025
  • 5 replies
  • 741 views

Hello everyone, can you please advise on how to share InDesign Projects with clients please?
I have 300 .indd files in one indesign master file.
Each of the 300 .indd files contains images and text.
I used Package using the master file and get a folder with Links that contains all the images and all the 300 .indd files.
Everything is great until I open the archive on another computer,  in this case, all links are missing and even if I relink the 300 .indd files, the images inside these 300 .indd files are not relinked even if they are on the Links folder.
How to handle this situation?
Thanks!

Adrian

5 replies

Inspiring
May 8, 2025

Thank you for taking time to respond, it is amazing to have so many people around.

Will check all the suggestions and let you know how this evolves.

Have a great day everyone!

Cheers!

Willi Adelberger
Community Expert
Community Expert
May 8, 2025

I woud place PDF/X-4 files instead of open INDD files into your master file. I am against embedding as it causes often damage.

Iwould put the 300 files into an InDesign book file fpor the purpose of pacaging. The bok files can eaxily be packaged from the book manu. Take care that every file starts with page 1 to not shuffle left and right pages.

Community Expert
May 8, 2025

Cannot stress enough - I've never had a damaged indesign file because of embedding. And there is a lot of people in the process doing it, globally, multiple versions of InDesign. It has never been a problem (touches wood). 

But I agree the placing of InDesign files is a cool thing, but it creates a rich inception level - so I agree that PDFX4a would be ideal - but it's 300 files now at this stage... so it's a lot of work to redo to PDFX4a and ensure all is ok. 

 

But yes, the PDF workflow is preferred.

Community Expert
May 8, 2025

I suspect the InDesign files that are linked into an InDesign file - these files have links that are not being packaged - is that what you're saying. 

 

That's a highly complex inception level structure - so the linked InDesign files are not being packaged and saving the linked images. 

 

One way to ensure they do package is to Embed all the images in all InDesign files. 

You will get massive InDesign files. 

I know some people here are totally against embedding images in InDesign files, but I do it all the time - it makes for a large InDesign file, but same as the packaged zip file anyway. 

 

There's a discussion here https://community.adobe.com/t5/indesign-discussions/embedding-images-in-many-files/td-p/10579791
Low and behold some against it some for it - and some scripts you could try.

 

I'd only try this on some sample documents to ensure it's working ok. 

 

But I think it would work in your siutation even if it's not the supercool popular method. 

 

Anyway - just an idea. Up to you if you want to go that road.

If people need to make edits they could unembed the image, make the change, and then reembed the image. 

 

I have a script that automatically embeds images when I hit File>Save - I can share it if you it helps - you could share with your client/collaborators to work the same way. 

 

So to put in a nutshell.

You'd have to open 300 indesign files - emebed all the images. 

Then open  your document with the 300 linked InDesign files

Then update the link for all 300 files

Then check all pages to make sure nothing went wonky.

 

Then when making an edit you open the main indesign file

Unembed the InDesign file that you're editing

Update the link in the indesing file by unemedding make the change etc. (or replace the emebedded link) 

Then reembded the image 

Then save the file (the embed can happe at save with A script I have)

Then back to to the main document 

Then update the InDesign file link

Then embed and save the file. 

 

Sounds like a lot of work.

But better than links going missing. 

 

 

I remember a long time ago working on a magazine and the folders were like Bike 1 Bike 2 Bike 3 etc. In each folder was Image 1 Image 2 Image 3 etc. 

Then when the file went through the RIP every bike on every page had Image 1 Image 2 Image 3 from Bike 1 folder. 

 

What I'm getting at - if you package all links into a folder and some links have the same name - it could cause unintended images in the wrong place. 

 

Well that's my idea. 

Peter Kahrel
Community Expert
Community Expert
May 7, 2025

InDesign uses absolute file paths for linked images, so when you move your package to a different computer the file paths will be invalid. You have two options: (1) use the same folder structure on the destination computer, or (2) use a script to relink the images in the placed InDesign files. There are various scripts around,  you can find them on the web.

Inspiring
May 7, 2025

Thank you so much! 

I'm extremely new into InDesign and I wonder which way is the easiest way to share editable InDesign projects with collaborators. 

Robert at ID-Tasker
Legend
May 7, 2025

@adriant89470497

 

What EXACTLY do you mean by "share with collaborators"?

 

Because, in the opening post, you've said that you need to "share with client" - which would suggest, that you're just giving away your files - after job has been done.

 

But now, it sounds, like you're planning on working on those files together? 

 

Joel Cherney
Community Expert
Community Expert
May 7, 2025

I like to use @Peter Kahrel 's packaging script.  It will be able to package all three hundred INDDs for you as a batch operation. I can't even begin to estimate how much time that one script has saved me, over the years. 

 

https://creativepro.com/files/kahrel/indesign/batch_convert.html

Inspiring
May 7, 2025

Thank you for such a quick answer.

It is not working for me, or I don't use it properly. If I save as .indd file, I get 1 file and the 300 .indd files inside it are not linked.
Same, if I choose Package.
I get all the images and all the 300 .indd files but opening the file on another computer they are not linked. 
Once again, I choose relink, now all the 300 .indd files are linked (I can do Edit Original), but all the images in each individual .indd file is missing. There is no way to ask the client to relink all 300 individual .indd files.

What am I doing wrong?

How do InDesign handles sharing nested projects?

Thanks!

 

Joel Cherney
Community Expert
Community Expert
May 8, 2025

How do InDesign handles sharing nested projects?

 

My question in response to this is just like @Robert at ID-Tasker's, to be honest: can you tell us the whole story? The people who are opening up your InDesign file, what exactly do they need to do? @Peter Kahrel mentioned scripts to relink images, which might work in your case. Imagine that your InDesign project is located on your Windows desktop, at C:\Users\YourWindowsUserName\Desktop\BigInDesignProject. Your client, or collaborator, or translator, or whatever? They're on a Mac, with the files located in maybe their Downloads folder, or their Completed Projects folder, or whatever. You'd need a one-click script that would revise the paths on the links to all 300 placed INDDs to match their current location on the other person's drive. Or you might be able to simply ensure that you and the people on the other end are using identical paths to prevent links being missing upon opening the INDD. 

 

Wouldn't it be faster to export 300 PDFs from your 300 INDDs? You could then package all 300 INDDs and provide them so that others could revise your work and export fresh PDFs. 

 

Are there many linked images in your 300 placed INDDs? I'd usually advise against relying on embedded images stored inside the INDD, but it is remotely possible that it might be your least bad option.