Skip to main content
josinepw
josinepw
Participant
February 4, 2021
Answered

parenthesis flipped in arabic text indesign

  • February 4, 2021
  • 1 reply
  • 1541 views

if i copy text from a word file, all arabic text is shown correct except the parenthesis. I've tried "world ready single line composer tricks", paragraph styles, languages... just cant solve it. Any ideas? I'm using indesign 15.1

     

This topic has been closed for replies.
Correct answer Zaid Al Hilali

I tested the file in InDesign 2021 on Mac OS Big Sur and Catalina. I Placed the Word file in InDesign and got the same unacceptable results as yours.

I tried Find/Replace in Word, and Find/Change in InDesign, but failed to change all parenthesis! I was able to replace one set of parenthesis such as this ) in Word and InDesign, but when I try to replace the other parenthesis ( it goes and change all or let's say both sides ( ) to this ) for example, which made me think that the Word file is buggy. It could be the way Word file was saved in the first place is to blame!

 

This is what I ended up doing, in Word I searched using Find/Replace for ( and replaced it to ), then replaced other parentheses manually. I Placed the file into InDesign and all was good. Same action can be done within InDesign using Find/Change to replace one side of Parenthesis, then manually change other side.

 

I know the above is not a solution, but I guess we have many variables involved such as…

  • Mac/Windows
  • Arabic/English
  • Adobe InDesign / M.S. Word

all these variables together contribute usually to problematic content which we need to address manually usually I'm afraid.

1 reply

Zaid Al Hilali
Community Expert
Zaid Al HilaliCommunity Expert
Community Expert
February 5, 2021

Did you try Placing (File > Place) the text from Word into InDesign instead of copying and pasting? Do you mind sharing a portion of the Word document for my testing so I can give you a sound suggestion?

josinepw
josinepwAuthor
Participant
February 5, 2021

Hi Zaid Al Hilali,

thank you for your reply. Yes i've tried that, see files attached.

Thank you for trying!

Zaid Al Hilali
Community Expert
Zaid Al HilaliCommunity ExpertCorrect answer
Community Expert
February 5, 2021

I tested the file in InDesign 2021 on Mac OS Big Sur and Catalina. I Placed the Word file in InDesign and got the same unacceptable results as yours.

I tried Find/Replace in Word, and Find/Change in InDesign, but failed to change all parenthesis! I was able to replace one set of parenthesis such as this ) in Word and InDesign, but when I try to replace the other parenthesis ( it goes and change all or let's say both sides ( ) to this ) for example, which made me think that the Word file is buggy. It could be the way Word file was saved in the first place is to blame!

 

This is what I ended up doing, in Word I searched using Find/Replace for ( and replaced it to ), then replaced other parentheses manually. I Placed the file into InDesign and all was good. Same action can be done within InDesign using Find/Change to replace one side of Parenthesis, then manually change other side.

 

I know the above is not a solution, but I guess we have many variables involved such as…

  • Mac/Windows
  • Arabic/English
  • Adobe InDesign / M.S. Word

all these variables together contribute usually to problematic content which we need to address manually usually I'm afraid.

    Terms & ConditionsAccessibility statement
    Using the community Terms of use Privacy Cookie preferences Do not sell or share my personal information ad choicesAdChoices