Skip to main content
D
defaultldmoxn5ne7lz
Participant
March 31, 2023
Answered

Partage pour révision - Couleurs fades

  • March 31, 2023
  • 1 reply
  • 821 views

Bonjour,

Je viens de partager mon document InDesign pour révision en générant un lien public (pour rappel, ce lien permet de consulter ce document sur n'importe quel navigateur).

Pourtant, lors de la consultation du document : les couleurs des images sont fades/ternes.

On dirait que le profil colorimétrique n'est pas conservé : est-ce une limitation de cette fonctionnalité ?

Existe-t-il un moyen pour faire en sorte que le profil soit conservé comme lors d'un export ?

Merci,

Cordialement

This topic has been closed for replies.
Correct answer Eugene Tyson

Eugene,

 

Thanks for your feedback, I agree if I wanted to get the same result everytime and everywhere.

 

You are right, let me show you:

 

You will notice a subtle difference between each version, even if your monitor is way different than mine: it seems that the InDesign version doesn't use any colour profile, colours are much blander, duller.
Maybe we can't use that feature (shared InDesign document) to work with high quality / rich colored pictures?

But it seems possible as the PDF works fine. What do you think?

 

Thanks for you help,

Regards


Honestly don't see a huge difference between the two. 

There is some artifacting going on in the one for Review online - I can see that without even zooming in. 

 

Here's my take on it - it's just my personal opinion:

Even if one of the reviewers is in a room with no windows and fluorescent lights on an uncalibrated monitor the colours would be different to someone sitting in a room with a monitor perpendicular to a window with good daylight and no lights on in the room.

 

Share for review is really only to make text/image change edits - I wouldn't count on it for someone to start colour correcting images or even talking about it.

 

Share for review, in my opinion, is to review the content/placement/edits etc. 

 

If someone is concerned about colour - you could send them a colour proof PDF or some pages of colour proofs to alieve their anxiety.

 

However, unless you get a RIPed proof from the printer viewed on a colour-corrected monitor in the correct lighting - you are going to see different values from someone else.

 

--------------

@rob day What do you think about this one? 

 

 

1 reply

E
Community Expert
Eugene TysonCommunity Expert
Community Expert
April 2, 2023

What computer/OS  - was it on a monitor or a mobile device? 

What are your settings, where are you viewing it? 

 

 

D
defaultldmoxn5ne7lzAuthor
Participant
April 3, 2023

Hello Eugene,

I work on Windows 10 Professionnal edition (Version 21H2 - 19044.2728) with a calibrated (i1Display) Thinkvision monitor (Lenovo).

I try to view my document on Google Chrome 11.0.5563.147, same result with Firefox (111.0.1).

My document use an Adobe RGB (1998) profile.

Thanks for your help.

Regards

E
Community Expert
Eugene TysonCommunity Expert
Community Expert
April 3, 2023

Without seeing the original and the result it's difficult to know what's going on.

 

And everyone's monitor is going to be different, and then you have different mobile devices and different tablets etc.

 

Typically browsers display in sRGB - even though they don't necessarily have a colour profile.

 

sRGB is a narrower gamut than Adobe RGB

Adobe RGB has a wider gamut than sRGB, particularly in the green and red areas of the spectrum. However, it's less compatible with many devices and applications, which can lead to colour shifting or inaccurate colour rendering when images are viewed outside of a colour-managed environment.

 

sRGB would be the standard color space for web content and digital imaging, while Adobe RGB is preferred for high-quality printing and photography.

 

 

Terms & ConditionsAccessibility statement
Using the community Terms of use Privacy Cookie preferences Do not sell or share my personal information ad choicesAdChoices