Skip to main content
Legend
November 4, 2021
Question

Table formats - what am I missing?

  • November 4, 2021
  • 1 reply
  • 169 views

Hello all!

I want to create a full table format. In my understanding, it would define the look of the cells (header and body) and even text. I can create cell formats to be nested in a table format, so the header cells can look different to the body cells. I can even assign text formats to the cell formats.

But what I can't do is to define a cell's minimum height or width in the cell format. I can do that manually the panel for table properties, but that's not the point when using formats. Even if I create a new cell format from an existing table cell that already has a specific height set, it would not be transferred.

 

Next thing, I created a table format which says the table shall have a stroke of 1 pt in black solid. The head row is linked to a cell format for head rows which has a 20% black fill. Applying that table format to any table would backfill the header as expected, but not put the stroke on the table. I also created another cell format for the body cells which also shall have 1 pt stroke in black solid. This is also linked in the table format, but not applied. No cell would have a stroke. The attached video shows that the setting for table frame or stroke of 1 pt isn't applied.

The second videoo show that creating and nesting a cell format with 1pt stroke wouldn't apply. It can only work if I manually assign the cell format, which seems to be overridden (by what?), and removed the deviations.

 

What am I missing? Or is this the way ID handles table formats so that, from my POV, it's pointless to use them? 

 

This topic has been closed for replies.

1 reply

Community Expert
November 4, 2021

Hi Doc Maik,

I think you are not missing much…

 

For serious table formatting I would recommend looking into a plug-in like SmartStyles from Woodwing:

https://www.woodwing.com/en/smart-styles-adobe-indesign-plugin

There is a free 30-days trial.

 

Regards,
Uwe Laubender

( ACP )

Doc MaikAuthor
Legend
November 4, 2021

I use ID 2019. Downloaded the version of Smart Styles for ID 2019, installed, started ID and there were only errors.

Will contact Woodwing. Thinking about it, I wondered if the plugin would require to have the cloud client running, which isn't on my PC. I have totally deactivated everything from CC. By the way, those CC tools (client, lib, experience) are the worst piece of software ever. Nagging, running in the background, stealing CPU power and resources - in one word: totally useless.