Skip to main content
Inspiring
January 30, 2026
Question

Will a grayscale .bmp placed in InDesign print okay?

  • January 30, 2026
  • 5 replies
  • 93 views

Hi there, 

If I place a grayscale bmp in InDesign will it print okay? I’m working with a brand that wants all their photos to look like duotones. So I’m turning the photo into a grayscale, saving as bmp, placing in Indesign and then colourizing it by choosing one brand colour as the background colour and the other as the “ink” colour (anything black in the photo will be this colour). Looks fine in Indesign. I’ve done test exports to pdf and it looks fine. and If I open up a page in Illustrator of the exported print pdf it looks fine, and I can see the placed BMP has been converted to a CYMK object which is fine for me. 

Their brand book suggests taking a grayscale image and then doing mode> bitmap and using dither, and then saving as a tiff, and following the same process in InDesign with colouring. However, when i tried the method, the preview in InDesign looked awful (even though high res preview is on) and the exports didn’t look as good (weird pdf artifacts that disappear when zooming in and out, but are a pain in the but to explain to clients). 


 

    5 replies

    Dave Creamer of IDEAS
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    January 31, 2026

    I would use grayscale TIFF for those images. (Just to clarify, the .BMP format is not the same as the Bitmap mode in Photoshop.)

    The advantage of doing a duotone in Photoshop is that you can edit the color application curves before converting to CMYK.

     

    David Creamer: Community Expert (ACI and ACE 1995-2023)
    JR Boulay
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    January 30, 2026

    Do not use the BMP format; choose any other image format instead (except EPS, of course).

    Acrobate du PDF, InDesigner et Photoshopographe
    rob day
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    January 30, 2026

    Their brand book suggests taking a grayscale image and then doing mode> bitmap and using dither,

     

    Hi ​@katielady1 , Also keep in mind if you convert to a dithered bitmap and apply a color (something other than black and white) there will have to be a halftone or stochastic screen applied to the colored dither at print output, which will likely cause an unexpected moire pattern. Make sure you get a hi res proof before going to the print run.

     

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moir%C3%A9_pattern

     

    Inspiring
    January 31, 2026

    Thank you! I was seeing that. I’m abandoning the dithered bitmap entirely. I’ll get the effect I want through some texture and using a psd. 

    Luke Jennings3
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    January 31, 2026

    I would suggest you use Acrobat or Reader to preview your pdf, instead of Illustrator.

    Community Expert
    January 30, 2026

    Using BMP grayscale to create a faux duotone in Indesign should not cause a print issue. You would have the same result using a TIFF grayscale. But the description from the brand book using a bitmap TIFF that is dithered will not produce the same result as either grayscale BMP or grayscale TIFF.

    Using a bitmap for solid art is OK as long as the resolution is maintained or increased when creating the bitmap.

    If the desired effect is a mezzotint, using Diffusion Dither converted to bitmap is OK and will print fine, but the display may be poor due to zoom, and other display settings.

    Inspiring
    January 30, 2026

    Thanks, Jeffrey. I agree the look is not exactly the same, but it’s close enough for me. Thanks for chiming in. 

    Peter Spier
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    January 30, 2026

    Offhand I can’t think of a reason why it wouldn’t print OK, but I’m curious why you choose to save as .bmp rather than .psd or even .tif

    Peter Spier
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    January 30, 2026

    Sorry, reading fast today and I see your reasoning. I think you should get the same results with ANY non-transparent grayscale image you treat this way. I suspect the artifacts you see in the PDF are just a screen draw issue, possibly related to jpeg conversion on export. Do you see the same artifacts if you use zip compression, or no compression, when exporting?