Skip to main content
ImaRetiredTeacher
Known Participant
June 21, 2024
Question

Can I purposely break a link?

  • June 21, 2024
  • 6 replies
  • 546 views

Hello all,

I'm not sure if this Q belongs here or somewhere else??

I believe my request will sound strange, but I need to purposely break a link between my Cr2 and the shortcut loaded into Lightroom Classic. Something strange happened to my subject's ears that I didn't notice until I thought I was done and was double checking everything at 200%. How did I miss the issue until then? The person is the seconday subject (small enough that Lightroom can't find a "person", appearing in a relatively small size. I brainstormed on how to not completely start over with this image and decided the following: I'd like to sever the original link, then reattach the Cr2 from a new location (unless there's a better solution) I honestly thought it would be as simple as moving the file to a different hard drive, but I was clearly wrong. I did discover something I didn't know existed--internet shortcuts. I thought maybe they were the problem, so I tried deleting them, but it doesn't work. I found instructions for deleting those by searching a Microsoft Forum. The solution was to go to the service I use, such as OneDrive, and get rid of it there first. My dilemma is ironic as I've accidentally broken links many times.

Because I learned to use computers later in my life, and never went to school for them, I have a limited working knowledge. I mostly only know how to do the things of which others instruct me.

To sum up, I only want to break the link to that one Cr2. 

Thanks in advance 😃

 

**UPDATE: I have spent scores of hours learning to use lightroom classic. Knowing the program really wasn't the issue. However, I've decided this was a freak occurrance that cannot be fixed. The RAW file reflects the ear was recorded in a ghost-like manner. I assume because it is a distant secondary subject and the sun had sunk too low for sufficient light to be recorded.

This topic has been closed for replies.

6 replies

Abambo
Community Expert
Community Expert
July 16, 2024

In addition to what has been said to correct an edit that got it wrong: To do a different editing, you can create a virtual copy. You can then start again edititing the asset as a new asset or you continue and do different adjustments to the virtual copy. Lightroom works like a cookbook. It stores the recipe, exporting is like cooking. The cooked meal is like the JPEG files. 

 

In lightroom, you have one golden rule: never doing file operations outside of lightroom. So once imported, you should use Lightroom for all operation where you would use Windows Explorer or macOS Finder.

 

(And do not forget to backup both, your image raw files and your Lightroom database.)

ABAMBO | Hard- and Software Engineer | Photographer
ImaRetiredTeacher
Known Participant
July 17, 2024

This shoot is just weird and I've already spoken with my model about a reshoot. I examined  the images carefully (hadn't yet formatted my memory card) and it's actually, strangely, captured that way. I've never had this happen before--didn't even know part of an ear could be "ghosted". However, I forgot my extra batteries on this shoot and had to run home to get them, which allowed the light to diminish. I think maybe that's why this happened. I decided it was simply prudent to reshoot. The model was my granddaughter so she works forStarbucks, haha. Everything happen's for a reason--I'll probably get even better shots 😃

Community Expert
June 23, 2024

Edits that you make on a CR2 (a kind of Raw file) have not committed any change irretrievably. Therefore if there's anything you now don't like or that you originally missed, you can just keep altering the editing further. This can include resetting altogther, or  reversing or updating edits selectively: whether global ones, or local ones (mask based). 

 

Clearly if you have already printed (or exported a JPG) then after updating this editing you might print again, or export another JPG, showing your latest work. 

 

OR: say you have two different original CR2s (from two different presses of the shutter button, but otherwise very similar). And you have edited A, but now you wish you had edited B instead.

 

Having made sure B is also imported alongside A: you can now Sync or else Copy/Paste your work between them: in other words, transfer a copy of all or selected kinds of edit from photo A, onto photo B. There may then be some tweaks needed to e.g. the locations of spot cloning, or to masking (where the underlying content of these two photos does not align). But you won't need to start completely from scratch with this other image.

 

 

This approach would be far better IMO, than trying to "switch in" a different Raw file underneath these same edits. Any strategy that depends on 'tricking' the software in some way, has as I see it already started out on the wrong foot. Just use it in a straightforward way, don't overthink, and try to go with its flow - is my recommendation.

dj_paige
Legend
June 23, 2024

If you feel you have made "bad edits" and want to start over from scratch on this photo, simply click the Reset button in the Develop Module. If you only want to undo some edits, use the History panel in the Develop Module to move backwards in time to a set of edits that makes you happier.

 

Breaking links, moving photo files and "internet links" are all the wrong thing to do, and can make the situation worse.

ImaRetiredTeacher
Known Participant
July 17, 2024

I didn't cause this through edits. After throughly examining the Cr2s, I decided going back wouldn't help anyway. What I shot must have been caused by low light conditions, although I've never seen such a thing. Her ear looks ghostlike in the original raw file so there's just no point. 

Nancy OShea
Community Expert
Community Expert
June 23, 2024

[Moderator moved from Stock Contributors to Lightroom Classic.]

 

Nancy O'Shea— Product User & Community Expert
Jill_C
Community Expert
Community Expert
June 21, 2024

It sounds like what you're really trying to do is undo the previously applied edits in LRC. You can do that by clicking Reset on the lower right corner in the Develop module. Or you can go to the history panel in the left and step back one edit at a time.

Jill C., Forum Volunteer
Jill_C
Community Expert
Community Expert
June 21, 2024

Your question should have been posted to the Lightroom Classic forum. To change the folder in which the image is stored, just drag and drop it from within LRC the new folder. It's important to do this within LRC, or LRC wont know how to find it. Think of LRC as a library catalog card file which knows where every image is located. If you "break that link" LRC won't know where to look. I suggest a good course for learning all the features of LRC. I learned from Ben Willmore on CreativeLive.com

Jill C., Forum Volunteer