Copy & Paste Settings Problem

Hi all, 

I've had this issue since the update, but whenever I paste settings onto another image, the photo looks desaturated and flatter. I understand not every image will look the same based on the lighting, but this happens even with photos taken milliseconds apart (I am a family photographer and spray-and-pray when little kids are laughing lol) so I know it's not a difference in lighting.

Is anyone else experiencing this after the update?! I didn't seem to find anyone else talking about this.

It's frustrating because I created a preset based on a few modifications I made on another one so I wouldn't have to make these changes to every single image, but now the images look completely different when pasting the settings.