Skip to main content
Known Participant
November 17, 2024
Question

I want to be able to subtract from a mask any other masks I have previously created

  • November 17, 2024
  • 1 reply
  • 861 views

Lightroom Classic Product Manager attn: do you have in your backlog a feature to enable subtracting not only what is available/possible there today, but also any previously user-created masks?

This topic has been closed for replies.

1 reply

johnrellis
Legend
November 17, 2024

See here for how to subtract an existing mask component from another one:

https://www.lightroomqueen.com/community/threads/masking-subtract-an-existing-mask.51582/#post-1343669

 

Known Participant
November 18, 2024

Thanks, I actually wasn't aware of this, but this is not a solution. Not only it is very cumbersome, but it seems to work only with brush-type masks, while object-type selection has "copy" disabled. Anyway, a mask almost never consists of one brush, so I want to be able to select the whole mask, consisting of several brushes, objects, etc.

johnrellis
Legend
November 18, 2024

"it seems to work only with brush-type masks, while object-type selection has "copy" disabled."

 

Interesting, Copy is disabled for all the AI mask components (Object, Subject, Background, Sky, People) but not non-AI components (Brush, Linear Gradient, etc.).  

 

But instead of doing Copy, right-click the component and do Duplicate, drag that component into the mask from which you want to subtract it, right-click the component, and do Subtract.

 

That you can duplicate but not copy AI components seems like a bug to me, but Adobe will probably consider it "as designed".

 

"this is not a solution. Not only it is very cumbersome ... I want to be able to select the whole mask, consisting of several brushes, objects, etc."

 

It's a solution but obviously one that involves more steps and is significantly less convenient. You can duplicate and subtract each of the components in the mask from the target mask.