Skip to main content
straightlife
Inspiring
Apr 13, 2020 7:26 PM UTC
Question

Is it just impossible? Sort by size?

It's such sophisticated software, but it seems we cannot sort by size. 

I'm not a well organized person.

I have thousands of photos.

When I go through my pictures, I'll see an image I want to use. I'll check the metadata and find that it is low res. Drat!

So then, I continue to scroll through my thousands of pictures looking for that same image (possibly with a different name) in a higher res.

Isn't there a better way?

Isn't there a way to group by size. BY SIZE????

I've been researching online. Once upon a time I used Jeffrey Friedl's plugin. It doesn't work any more.

Should I go into the actual files (outside of dropbox) and try to make a database by names and sizes?

I know it's my fault for not setting it up intelligently, but please, if anybody has a suggestion at this late date....?

 

11 replies

Community Expert
Nov 6, 2026 2:44 PM UTC

I agree that where multiple instances of the same photo are imported, we will usually want to work from a full resolution file if possible. And that means distinguishing between those and other reduced versions, after being presented with a jumbled mixture (say, as search results).

One solution is a naming scheme for exports which can filter them out from camera original files / externally edited copies of those.from camera original files. 

Another is when the file types are functionally different: Raw (vs) TIF or PSD (vs) JPG, for example. 

Another is simply to avoid having any files imported in the Catalog that are not in their full original resolution. Then there is no need to make that distinction - because ALL of the images seen are expected to be editing- and export-suitable. Like a library where everything on the shelves is a full book as published, without partial photocopies people have made from those books being intermixed too.

This means: not reimporting exported image versions; if externally editing in PS, altering picture content only within that environment but not downsizing, geometric transforming, or making presentational changes such as B&W conversion or cropping. It’s efficient IMO to leave such treatments to apply only once an image returns from PS to LrC, where with virtual copies available one can then vary these treatments multiply and nondestructively. So that works substantially the same as for an image that has not passed though PS.

Reduced resolution will then only happen within exported images - whether generated by LrC or by PS - as files which are accessed from outside of the Catalog. I prefer these derivative files in a discrete storage location, not intermixed among the Catalog-imported stuff and not necessarily to the same folders organisational scheme incidentally. This ‘distinction by purpose’ leads to a much easier life overall, in my experience.

Translate
Participant
Nov 6, 2026 1:59 PM UTC

6 years in and Adobe still hasn’t created a native function to organize all your files by size. Such an amazing company! They also will still charge you a monthly fee for this amazing product that doesn’t have basic functions. So good!

Translate
dj_paige
Legend
Nov 6, 2026 2:12 PM UTC

If whatever software it is you are complaining about doesn’t meet your needs, I and many others will be delighted if you found something that works better for you.

Also, I think the reason they have not implemented this feature is that they don’t want to implement this feature (and have valid reasons to think that file size is a misleading measure of image characteristics and quality). And I applaud this amazing company for making this decision.

Translate
Participant
Nov 6, 2026 3:14 PM UTC

Look, it’s Adobe’s #1 Ride or Die. FWIW, my comment was in regard to Adobe’s cloud storage. While I recognize this thread is for LrC and probably not the best place for it, it was the only thread I quickly found that talked about this feature. I agree with you that Adobe’s actual editing software is top tier, which is why I prefer using it and have done so for so long. But when it comes to managing all your cloud storage across all platforms, it would be nice to organize your files and folders by size so you can quickly find the biggest users of storage. I have fully maxed out my 1TB of cloud storage, so I either need to buy more storage, clean up my assets, or start using offline storage. It would be nice to be able to sort by file size in the Creative Cloud desktop app or through the web browser. But like you said, this feature is probably deliberately left out to make it more difficult to manage and clean up your assets when your cloud storage is full, making you just buy more cloud storage. So yeah, a great business decision when it comes to getting more money from your users. Anyways, I should probably carry my rant somewhere else that’s not in a LrC thread. Thank you and Goodnight. 

Translate
johnrellis
Legend
Apr 14, 2020 10:51 PM UTC

To summarize your options:

 

- Consider the Teekesselchen plugin for identifying near-duplicates.

 

- The Any Filter and Data Explorer plugins can create collections sorted by total megapixels, length or width, or file size in megabytes (or many other metadata fields).

 

- The Search Replace Transfer plugin can filter by file size, and the Any Filter plugin can filter by file size, megapixels, length, or width.

 

[Use the blue reply button under the first post to ensure replies sort properly.]

Translate
johnrellis
Legend
Apr 14, 2020 10:43 PM UTC

"I used Jeffrey Friedl's plugin. It doesn't work any more."

 

If you're referring to the Data Explorer plugin, it still works and is supported. If your installation isn't working, you might contact Friedl for support.

Translate
Known Participant
Apr 14, 2020 9:55 PM UTC

Check out John Beardsworth's Search Replace Transfer plug-in - it performs a number of valuable metadata functions, and lets you add fields like size (MB) and pixel dimensions (example 3000 x 2000) to the Metadata fields you can search with the Lightroom filter bar.  A web search should find John's site and the plugin, and  I believe he sometimes posts to this forum.  Basically, after you install the snapshot, select the photos you want to be able to filter and use the "Workflow Filters" function to define and populate the custom searchable fields.

 

I'm not aware of anything that searches for pictures that look the same, although if your derivative versions keep the originals' capture dates you may be able to sort or filter on that - without any plugin... Depends on how you created the derivatives.


Once you straighten out your situation with redundant copies of files, consider only keeping the master copy in Lightroom and producing prints or exporting if you need other size files.  You don't have to reimport those to Lightroom... and if you want ready access to different versions of a file (develop treatments, crop, etc) , look at the lightroom snapshot and virtual copy functions.  Much easier than proliferating multiple real copies.  I only keep original RAW files in LR.  The only exceptions are any reimported panos or HDRs, and occasionally the full-size (16 bit layered TIFF) output of PS if I had to do something to a picture in PS outside of LR that I want to save

 

I have no connection with the plugin other than as a user for several years.

 

Good luck!

Translate
GoldingD
Legend
Apr 13, 2020 10:17 PM UTC

You would need to use a plug-in. Never tried this one, simple google search finds this one in a split second.

 

http://regex.info/blog/lightroom-goodies/megapixel-sort

 

 

 

Translate
straightlife
Inspiring
Apr 14, 2020 9:11 PM UTC

Yeah. NICE plugin! It used to work, but it doesn't work anymore. 

Translate
dj_paige
Legend
Apr 13, 2020 7:46 PM UTC

Smart Collections let you filter (not sort) by megapixels.

 

There are only limited types of sorts avaialble in Lightroom, sort by image size is not one of them.

Translate
Lauca
Participating Frequently
Apr 13, 2020 7:32 PM UTC

I your purpose is to identify duplicate images and get rid of the smaller one(s), then you might consider using the free LR plugin Teekesselchen . It is very fast and efficient. In any case most efficient than sorting manually.

Translate