Skip to main content
This topic has been closed for replies.

3 replies

Rico_LR3
Participating Frequently
June 11, 2013

Luckily, no facial recognition in LR 5! I hope Adobe team will go on focusing on speed improvements, because LR5 is still not a racing car... and on some other features and improvements before facial recognition!

June 11, 2013

Rico_LR3 wrote:

Luckily, no facial recognition in LR 5! I hope Adobe team will go on focusing on speed improvements, because LR5 is still not a racing car... and on some other features and improvements before facial recognition!

yeah because that has worked so well in the past years. 

you guys still believe the "focus on" nonsense you come up with?

oh yeah i see .... you rather spend on upgrade after upgrade to get closer to the speed you should have from the start then new features.... ingenious!!

Rico_LR3
Participating Frequently
June 11, 2013

Hum, my english is not good enough to understand clearly what you mean.

But if you want me to say that I'm disapointed by LR5, well I am. If you think that LR 5 is slow, that LR4 was slow, and LR3 was slow and that we are still waiting for a normally speedy software, I'm with you. And I also think that LR5 doesn't worth the upgrade and that Adobe make us pay for a bug fix upgrade.

But that said, I'm waiting for other new features than facial recognition, like multiple users, decent thethered capture, multiple catalog opened at once, export improvement, a really good healing tool... Facial recognition is useless for me... but maybe not for you, I can understand!

Ian Lyons
Community Expert
Community Expert
June 10, 2013

No facial recognition.

Participating Frequently
June 10, 2013

Thank you, then no sale for the lazy adobe team

Victoria Bampton LR Queen
Community Expert
Community Expert
June 10, 2013

Lazy? You're kidding, right?  It's been only 15 months since LR4's release, and this is quite a lot of changes to fit into that time period. IMHO the performance improvements alone make it a great upgrade.

Victoria - The Lightroom Queen
areohbee
Legend
June 10, 2013

Why don't you download it, and then tell us?!

January 31, 2014

I'm absolutely astounded.  I have spent many hours learning Lightroom 5.  I took the Adobe courses; I took Steel Training.  I have spent many, many hours rating my photos and sorting them and creating smart collections.  I couldn't find facial recognition; nor could I find a way to write a description of a photo, something more than a few tags.  Last night I was working on my Mac Air, and I found to my utter amazement that not only does it have most all the same controls as lightroom for improving and editing a photo, and not only can I write a narrative about what we were doing and what the event was all about, but it asked me to label a face!  Then, the iPhoto told me it located 176 other photos with that face. it asked if I wanted to confirm them.  With a startling degree of accuracy, it displayed all the photos of that face and more.  All I had to do was CONFIRM or indicate that the face was NOT the same person.  It identified MY photo with and without a beard, mustache, hair, (and now 40 years later) bald.  It was absolutely unbelievable.  I didn't care that it had a few photos of my kids!  THey LOOK like me in facial bone structure.  It was amazing. 

Look ADOBE.  I don't have time to label 45000 old photos to find and designate one at a time with Keywords designating my various family members.  USE MATH! USE PROBABILITY.  It's obvious that the most recurring faces are my family and I don't mind labeling hundreds at a time while indicating the occasional error.  STOP trying to make your program perfect and give us facial recognition.  If it's not coming soon, let me know.  I am done fooling around trying to label thousands of old photos with the names of the people in them. 

As to the ability to write a brief narrative about a photo, I guess there must be a way, but after going through your videos and those of Phil Steele, I have yet to find it.  Don't you want to say something like - "After the wedding, we went over to Joe's place and played cards all night.  We were so wrecked for work on Monday."  You CANT put that in Key words alone.  How do I write my story!???   

Now I have to give up all I've put into the rating systems, and learning how to store photos in external drives, and backing up, etc.  becuase there is NO WAY I CAN JUSTIFY KEEPING YOUR PROGRAM when I can get the same photo manipulations tools PLUS narrative space AND facial recognition on MAC INCLUDED IN THE COST OF THE COMPUTER. 

I'd like to stay with you; please advise WHEN, if ever, YOU are going to release FR.  I don't care if it's perfect!  It's just a numbers game; give me 85 or 90% accuracy to lighten the load. 

Thanks!

Geoff the kiwi
Community Expert
Community Expert
January 31, 2014

You obviously cannot read Caption..... ranting here will do nothing. I suggest you might be happier sticking with iPhoto.