Skip to main content
Inspiring
December 8, 2024
Question

Lightroom Classic creating thousands of duplicate RAW photos on my drive.

  • December 8, 2024
  • 1 reply
  • 832 views

I just found out that lightroom has created thousands and thousands of duplicate photos of some of my collections.  I've used Lrc for many years and do not believe it is user error.  It did this once before and I had to start my collection over.  I've spent all year and I'm only halfway through recreating my catalog of travel photos from backups.

My actual photo files are organized by year/month.  2024/July originally had about 300 photos when I imported it in August.  Now the folder has 2,110 photos - some of them duplicated up to 6 times.  They are not virtual copies.  Theres no telling how many other duplicate photos it's made in other folders.  On the last catalog it created 11,000 duplicate raws that I could easily find and unknown amount of others. 

I can use AllDup to go through the files to find the duplicates and delete them from my drive, leaving the largest file of each grouping of duplicates.  Thats fairly easy.  Some are only single duplicates that have both NEF and DNG.  When I import my Nikon raw NEF files I always convert them to DNG inside of LrC.  I looked and I do have the "delete originals after successful conversion" checked.  I've made sure every single time.

But when I get all of the duplicates deleted from my SSD how to do bulk tell LrC to use the remaining files?

How do I stop LrC from creating additional duplicates in the future?  This is so insanely frustrating.

I use the C drive / main system drive for my catalog and image tiles.  No external drives are used.  It's a 2TB drive.

This topic has been closed for replies.

1 reply

dj_paige
Legend
December 8, 2024

The only time LrC creates "duplicates" of your RAW files is if you use the option in the Import dialog. Do you have this option checked?

 

 

 

Other than that, LrC does not have the ability to make duplicates of your photos.

 

It seems like a remote possibility, but the only other thing I can think of is that somehow you are importing the previews or smart previews that LrC makes. Are these files truly NEF or DNG, or are they some other file type? What is the full file name and file type of one of these "duplicates"???

JohanElzenga
Community Expert
Community Expert
December 8, 2024

The second way of creating duplicates is by importing photos that are already on the hard drive, and then using 'Copy' instead of 'Add' or 'Move'. A very common error.

 

The third way is to import the photos in Lightroom desktop as well, while having the Lightroom Classic catalog synced. Lightroom Classic may download these photos from the cloud again if you do not import the photos from the exact same location as Lightroom Classic uses. And Lightroom desktop copies photos before it imports them...

 

-- Johan W. Elzenga
dj_paige
Legend
December 8, 2024

Good point. It all boils down to (in each scenario) that the user is telling LrC to create these duplicates, LrC is not doing it on its own.