Skip to main content
September 19, 2021
Question

Lightroom Classic Profile Confusion

  • September 19, 2021
  • 3 replies
  • 258 views

Hi everyone. As a new photographer and new to Lightroom Classic, I am really confused by the Profile dropdown in the Basic section of the Develop tab. When I imported my RAW files, the profile showed as Adobe RGB. I erroneously clicked on the Profile dropdown and now I cannot get Adobe RGB back. I intend to deliver to sRGB as it seems to be the most consistent color space for today's web-based consumers. At any rate, as I am clicking through the different profiles, they each obviously display color differently. My question is, if each profile displays color differently, then when I make a color adjustment to my image, how will I know what the final image will look like? It seems that depending on which profile you select, you run the risk of over/under-correcting the image. Why not just have an sRGB option and leave all the profiles out of the equation? Google searches just come back with the standard Adobe RGB vs sRGB, which is better-type results.

 

Any help would be appreciated. 

This topic has been closed for replies.

3 replies

GoldingD
Legend
September 19, 2021
Todd Shaner
Legend
September 19, 2021

The following article on Lightroom Tone Control Adjustment should be helpful.

 

https://helpx.adobe.com/lightroom-classic/help/tone-control-adjustment.html

 

GoldingD
Legend
September 19, 2021

1 PROFILES not Color Space

 

The profiles are the analogy's to translate the RAW data to viewable data. What profile you use is a personal preference. Each one is designed for a different look. Their are some Adobe provided ones, and depending on camera, some camera matching ones. Camera matching profiles are very camera specific. You can also obtain third party profiles (often camera specific). The camera specific ones are designed to mimic the in camera film simulations (or whatever your camera calls them). Third party ones, often mimic specific film stock.

(https://www.phototraces.com/b/lightroom-raw-profiles/)

note that the Adobe normal profiles, are their self's, camera specific to some amount. 


IMO, selecting a profile should be Develop Module step one, it is no surprise that Adobe places it up near the top.

 

Selecting the correct profile for your vision, can save a lot of edit steps.

 

What profile you select will effect everything that follows. Some edits will look different based on the profile selected.

 

IMO, if you decide to use a different profile, then start over, do not select profiles upon profiles.

 

Note, if you want to try different profiles to see what happens, then create virtual copy's.

 

 

2. Color Space, not Profiles

 

As to sRGB, at start, NO, that is a color space, that would be applied at export, and used if you are publishing the export to the web.

 

Now it should be noted that LrC in the Develop module uses ProPhoto RGB color space, and you cannot change that. Anf in Library module LrC uses Adobe RGB color space., and you cannot change that. This is why Develop previews and Library previews do not look 100% the same, small differences, and why critique should be in Develop module. (https://helpx.adobe.com/ca/lightroom-classic/kb/color-faq.html)

 

note: you can soft proff to look at how the image will look, sort of.

(https://helpx.adobe.com/lightroom-classic/help/develop-module-options.html)

 

3. Color Matching Profiles

 

These are profiles designed by Adobe to mimic in camera settings, The various camera manufacturers have different names for these.

 

  • Fujifilm has Film Simulations (that match Fuji Film stock)
  • Cannon has Picture Styles
  • Nikon has Picture Control
  • Sony has Creative Style
  • Olympus has Picture Mode

 

Cameramatching profiles are camera model/version specific, Camera matching profiles for say a Fujifilm X-T4are not for say a Canon EOS 5, heck they are not even for a Fujifilm X-t3, tnst specific.

 Note that not all cameras have camera matching profiles, Canon users are especially pissed on that one.