Known Participant

Answered

LrC denoise and Sony a7iii

Forum|Forum|1 year ago
July 3, 2024
3 replies
772 views

I shot only in raw (.arw) with my Sony a7iii and never had a problem with using denoise before - now, it says that this type of file is incompatible...what gives?

macOS

This topic has been closed for replies.

Correct answer Conrad_C

If I open a RAW image straight into PS, it opens first in RAW and Denoise is present and working.
By @dougbraz

OK, so that means AI Denoise is working in the Camera Raw code, nothing is blocking it at the system level. Lightroom Classic uses its own separate copy of the same code, so that would indicate something wrong with Lightroom Classic only.

If I am in LrC, right click to open/edit the image in PS, it opens straight in PS and then I have to use filters to open Camera Raw and denoise in NOR available at all!
By @dougbraz

That sounds normal and expected, because when an image is opened from Lightroom Classic into Photoshop, it’s converted from raw to a Photoshop document. If you then apply Camera Raw as a filter, there are two definite reasons AI Denoise does not work that way:

1) AI Denoise currently works on raw files only, so it would not be expected to work on what is now no longer raw and converted to a Photoshop document.

2) AI Denoise is not available in the Camera Raw Filter, only in Camera Raw when used as an import plug-in or a raw Smart Object layer.

Just updated LrC a few hours ago, so denoise now works there with RAW files.
By @dougbraz

Oh, does that mean the problem is now resolved in Lightroom Classic?

GoldingD

Legend

was their a recent firmware update in the Sony?

D

dougbrazAuthor

Known Participant

not for the sony a7iii (ILCE-7M3) - just other newer models. Mine has version 4.01 which I understand to be the latest version.

GoldingD

Legend

Looks like that firmware update only fixed a battery level bug, not any additions to RAW formats. (thinking a new RAW format that is not supported in LrC DeNoise, that you may have accidentally used)

https://www.sony.com/electronics/support/e-mount-body-ilce-7-series/ilce-7m3/software/00257839

In the community, a member with a A7IV has an issue that may relate to the firmware.

https://community.adobe.com/t5/lightroom-classic-discussions/p-sony-a7iv-new-firmware-1-10-compatibility-issue/m-p/13207107

In the firmware updates for your camera, I do not see that mod listed. So probably not the issue.

Conrad_C

Community Expert

That’s weird, and unexpected. I have .arw files from an A7c and AI Denoise still works for them in Lightroom Classic 13.4, macOS 14.5.

Just to cross-check…do you have Photoshop installed, and if you open one of the .arw files into Adobe Camera Raw through Photoshop (or Bridge), is AI Denoise available there? This is only to determine whether the AI Denoise problem is affecting Lightroom Classic only, or also Camera Raw, in case that helps troubleshoot.

D

dougbrazAuthor

Known Participant

Interesting...

If I open a RAW image straight into PS, it opens first in RAW and Denoise is present and working.

If I am in LrC, right click to open/edit the image in PS, it opens straight in PS and then I have to use filters to open Camera Raw and denoise in NOR available at all!

Any reason why this should be happening? Just updated LrC a few hours ago, so denoise now works there with RAW files.

Conrad_C

Correct answer

Community Expert

If I open a RAW image straight into PS, it opens first in RAW and Denoise is present and working.
By @dougbraz

OK, so that means AI Denoise is working in the Camera Raw code, nothing is blocking it at the system level. Lightroom Classic uses its own separate copy of the same code, so that would indicate something wrong with Lightroom Classic only.

If I am in LrC, right click to open/edit the image in PS, it opens straight in PS and then I have to use filters to open Camera Raw and denoise in NOR available at all!
By @dougbraz

That sounds normal and expected, because when an image is opened from Lightroom Classic into Photoshop, it’s converted from raw to a Photoshop document. If you then apply Camera Raw as a filter, there are two definite reasons AI Denoise does not work that way:

1) AI Denoise currently works on raw files only, so it would not be expected to work on what is now no longer raw and converted to a Photoshop document.

2) AI Denoise is not available in the Camera Raw Filter, only in Camera Raw when used as an import plug-in or a raw Smart Object layer.

Just updated LrC a few hours ago, so denoise now works there with RAW files.
By @dougbraz

Oh, does that mean the problem is now resolved in Lightroom Classic?

dj_paige

Legend

Perhaps you set the camera to take downsized mRaw or sRaw photos.

D

dougbrazAuthor

Known Participant

No, I set the canera for uncompressed raw files only.

dj_paige

Legend

No, I set the canera for uncompressed raw files only.

By @dougbraz

This is not the compression setting in your camera. It is downsizing (which is different from compression), and you need to check that setting in your camera to be sure the files are not the downsized mRaw or sRaw. mRaw and sRaw will have fewer megapixels than the sensor captures, and LrC AI Denoise cannot work with these. If the only thing you change is compression, the number of megapixels doesn't change, and LrC should be fine.

Sign up

To post, reply, or follow discussions, please sign in with your Adobe ID.

Sign in to Adobe Community

To post, reply, or follow discussions, please sign in with your Adobe ID.

Scanning file for viruses.

This file cannot be downloaded