Skip to main content
Heirloom Bob
Inspiring
Aug 18, 2023 11:39 PM UTC
Answered

P: Edit in PS from Lightroom does not open the image in PS

Have an edited image in Lightroom that I want to continue editing with Photoshop. Right click opens PS but the image doesn't move into PS. Instead the Photoshop window opens with my most recent images showing but no way to move the lightroom image to PS.

Windows 11, PS 24.7.0 and LR 12.5

 

[Merged several similar messages into this one thread in order not to have the same question (and suggestion to solve it) in several threads. Mod]

This topic is closed to new replies. Start a new post to keep the conversation going.
JohanElzenga
JohanElzengaCorrect answer
Community Expert
Sep 10, 2023 2:58 PM UTC

I have been reluctant to process this "fix" as I have installed, Topaz, Nik, Sky replacement images etc etc. I assume I will have to do this again after the PS LR reinstall?

 

Bob


quote

I have been reluctant to process this "fix" as I have installed, Topaz, Nik, Sky replacement images etc etc. I assume I will have to do this again after the PS LR reinstall?

 

Bob


By @Heirloom Bob


Yes, you may have to reinstall some stuff (although you could probably just move the plugins out of the plugins folder and move them back in after reinstalling Photoshop), but do you want to fix this or not? If you want to fix this, then you'll have to accept that it could mean some extra work.

 

-- Johan W. Elzenga

74 replies

Art4hire
Participating Frequently
Sep 10, 2023 11:05 PM UTC

I ran into the same problem today. Sigh... I managed a bit of a workaround by opening the orginal RAW file from Photoshop, editing it in Camera RAW and Photoshop and saving the file as a unique name. I then synchronized the folder containing the edited image(s) in Lightroom. It's a bulky workaround for sure but I'm leery of reinstalling PS and LR for fear of losing personal actions, presets, AFM filters, and plugins etc. So for me, that's what I'll do until the programmers at Adobe figure out how to fix the problem and provide updates.

Translate
JohanElzenga
Community Expert
Community Expert
Sep 11, 2023 1:48 PM UTC

Suit yourself, but don't hold your breath. This problem has been around from time to time for many years, so holding your breath while waiting for a fix could be very unhealty...

 

Translate
-- Johan W. Elzenga
bigoudy007
Participating Frequently
Sep 10, 2023 8:04 AM UTC

Hello all,
I have the same problem 😔. The "smart object" solution is not viable for me.

Translate
Participant
Sep 10, 2023 7:31 AM UTC

Hi all, I'm seeking a current fix for a problem that looks like it's happened to many of you previously.  I have LR Classic v12.5 and PS v24.7 and am using a Mac with Ventura 13.4.1
All was working fine up until yesterday, but today images will not open in PS from LR.  PS opens, but there are no images visible.  I've closed/opened LR & PS and also restarted the computer, but to no avail.  
Any troubleshooting advice very much appreciated.

Translate
bigoudy007
Participating Frequently
Sep 10, 2023 7:51 AM UTC

Hello,

I have the same problem

Translate
JohanElzenga
Community Expert
Community Expert
Sep 10, 2023 9:22 AM UTC

To all in this thread: try the uninstall/reinstall suggestion. If you did do that and it did not solve the problem, then report it here. Just saying "I have the same problem" does not help.

 

Translate
-- Johan W. Elzenga
Mark Cohran
Participant
Sep 10, 2023 6:37 AM UTC

Same issue here. I've not found a fix for it yet.

 

Translate
Mark Cohran
Participant
Sep 10, 2023 6:49 AM UTC

Opening by choosing Open as a Smart Object in Photoshop will open the file and seems to allow edits, but won't allow saving the file. Attempting to save returns an "Error21: undefined is not an object. Line 1"  as an error. Hitting OK still does not allow saving the file. I'm leery of the proposed fix or uninstalling the programs because I'm unsure if that will require reinstalling the various plugins (Imogenic Portraiture and various Topaz files) after the reinstall.  

Translate
Mark Cohran
Participant
Sep 10, 2023 6:30 PM UTC

Deinstalled LR and PS and then reinstalled PS then LR Classic in that order. Issue seems to be resolved and I managed to keep all my plugins, presets and actions. 

Translate
Participant
Sep 9, 2023 6:10 PM UTC

Hi, today when I try to send a pic from lightroom classic to photoshop for editing, the photoshop homescreen opens but the pic will not open in photoshop. I have been using this workflow for years and nefer had any issues until today. I'm using Lightroom Classic 12.5 release and Photoshop 2023 24.7.0 release, and I work on a Macbook Pro. Can anyone help me out?

Translate
Participant
Sep 9, 2023 6:25 PM UTC

I have the same issue opn my i mac since upgrading to ventura 13.5.2. I can only get the photo in if I do it as a smart object. Then when trying to sve it i get an error 21 message and cannot savbe the image.

Translate
Heirloom Bob
Inspiring
Sep 8, 2023 11:42 PM UTC

Learned something. If I select the top Edit in Photoshop 2023, the behavior is exactly as I described BUT if I select further down in the list, Photoshop 2023, it opens as it should. Makes no sense to me.

 

Translate
Known Participant
Sep 9, 2023 2:31 AM UTC

I have the same issue as above and a repeat of last month when Lightroom was unable to open an image into Photoshop 2023. I have updated my macOS recently to 13.5.2 and updated all Adobe PS and LR and Beta PS

 

Photoshop 2023 just site there after Cmd E promt and or right click "Edit in Photoshop 2023" The only way around the issue is to open the file from its folder by right click "open in photoshop" and the image then goes to Camera Raw and then into Photoshop. Why has this issue returned after fixes last month. Very frustration

Ken 

Translate
JohanElzenga
Community Expert
Community Expert
Sep 9, 2023 8:48 AM UTC

What usually works is uninstalling both Lightroom and Photoshop, and then reinstalling Photoshop first and Lightroom second. The order of reinstalling is vital.

 

Translate
-- Johan W. Elzenga
lukep43316151
Participant
Aug 18, 2023 11:39 PM UTC

Mac OSX Ventura 13.5

Lightroom Classic 2023 - 12.5 release

Photoshop 2023 - 24.7.0 release

 

In Lightroom, I use 'open as layers in photoshop' all the time for compositing interior images. Last week the function stopped working?

Today there was a Lightroom update which I was hoping would fix the issue. It hasn't!

I have tried the suggestions stated on previous posts but haven't found a fix as yet.

This is extremely frustrating as has slowed down my workflow immeasurably.

Any and all suggestion are very welcome... especially from Adobe directly.

Cheers

Luke

Translate
lukep43316151
Participant
Aug 19, 2023 12:06 AM UTC

What is happening: 

I select 2 images in Lightroom.

Choose Photo > Edit In > Open As Layers In Photoshop.

Photoshop launches/opens

But nothing further happens.

 

Translate