Skip to main content
Participant
October 29, 2017
Question

Replacement for LR with good book module

  • October 29, 2017
  • 2 replies
  • 528 views

Years ago, I decided to use Aperture instead of LR.  It started getting long in the tooth and when Apple stopped its development, I decided to make the jump to LR.  While photo edits and more advanced features were present in LR, the one thing that was never up to par was the Book Module.  LR's instantiation of the Book module was a far cry from the UX provided by Aperture.  It was amazing to me that the Book and Print modules behave differently and demonstrated Adobe's fragmentation within their own products.  One thing I really liked about Aperture's book module was the ability to put anything anywhere on the page and the back-and-forth between image editing and the book module (allowing me to change the way a picture looks based on the feel of a specific book/page set).

Now that Adobe is end-of-lifing LR Classic, I'm wondering about switching photo management/editing software again.  In so doing, I'd really like to get back to something with a great book layout implementation.  Also, given all the face tagging, keywords, and events that I've done in LR, I'd also want something that would transfer those.  And, of course, I'd want something that might be able to read my edited files so that I don't have to re-edit everything on transfer.  I'm curious if there is anything that might meet these criteria in the experience of those on this forum.  Is there anything that might give me the better UX experience of Aperture, the image editing power of LR, and allow me to transition my photos and edits?

    This topic has been closed for replies.

    2 replies

    Inspiring
    October 30, 2017

    Now that Adobe is end-of-lifing LR Classic

    That's false. Facebook is no place to get your news.

    Books: blurb.com, shutterfly.com, snapfish.com, others. I've forgotten who produced the Aperture books, but Shutterfly comes to mind.

    Rob_Cullen
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    October 30, 2017

    First- IMO Lightroom is NOT "end-of-lifing" LR-Classic. Millions of professionals and amateurs would be up-in-arms if Adobe were to put an end to Lr-Classic. I presume to are referring to the 'end' of "Perpetual" versions (v6).

    Second- There is nothing (at present) that can migrate the proprietary Adobe edits of your photos to another program. Only an 'Export to TIFF' will preserve the edited version in a full pixel size file.

    You could continue to use Lr-6.13 (until operating system upgrades render it useless), or good-luck in finding alternatives such as 'on-line' Book design like Blurb Bookwright.

    Regards. My System: Windows-11, Lightroom-Classic 15.1.1, Photoshop 27.3.1, ACR 18.1.1, Lightroom 9.0, Lr-iOS 10.4.0, Bridge 16.0.2 .