Participating Frequently

Question

Sony A7RV camera profiles

Forum|Forum|2 years ago
April 20, 2024
2 replies
4841 views

The camera matching profiles for the A7RV couldn't be further from camera matching. I click them and suddenly people's skin turn red. My camera does not give red skin tones in the jpeg files it takes. Do these need looking at again?

J

Jao vdL

Community Expert

One of those threads where screenshots and sample files would be good. It is entirely possible that Adobe made some mistakes in doing the camera matching profiles or used a preproduction version of the camera and Sony made changes to the sensor afterwards (it has happened before). Usually the camera matching profiles are quite good and close to the jpegs. In the past, Adobe has had to release updated camera matching profiles for some cameras where there was a big mismatch.

C

Christopher34217843u3xrAuthor

Participating Frequently

I will share some later on.

maximilianw28931415

Participant

"couldn't be further from camera" is very mild wording for the actual problems I've seen so far. Color gradients get completly messed sometimes. Especially in clouds/skies. Often purple artifacts are introduced by Lightroom/Camera Raw. This is not GPU/screen/color-calibration related. It is purely the fault of Adobe's camera-matching profiles for Sony cameras in Lightroom/Camera Raw. I hope they will fix it soon because I am (still) a longterm user of Lightroom. But this makes it ridiculous.

I don't like using the Adobe profiles either because this would mean starting my edits too far away from what those pictures should look like. Nikon and Fujifilm camera-matching profiles are much better and I am having much more fun with those in Lightroom.

D Fosse

Community Expert

Camera matching profiles are a compromise, offered because of public demand.

These are entirely different raw processing engines. Trying to make one raw processor look exactly like another is basically impossible. That doesn't mean one is more "correct" or "better" than the other, just that they will always be slightly different.

You will always get better results by letting Lightroom use its own algoritms natively as they are intended to work.

I have that camera and I think Lightroom treats the files beautifully. But I have never used the camera matching profiles, for this reason.

C

Christopher34217843u3xrAuthor

Participating Frequently

Personally I don't like lightrooms rendering of the Sony files I think the colour is awful and lifeless straight out the gate that's why I wanted to try camera matching because seeing the straight out of camera JPEGs the colour was pretty good, Sony did a decent job on this camera with colour science.

I have a a competitor program that I also use and that renders the Sony files so much nicer straight out the gate but Lightroom has its advantages in other ways for certain kinds of jobs.

D Fosse

Community Expert

For what it's worth, I took a bunch of random portrait shots and ran them through different camera matching profiles for the a7rV. They all looked...horrible. That's the only word for it. So no argument from me on that particular count.

But the thing is - they look terrific with the Adobe Color profile. So why would anyone use any other profile? I don't get it. Sure, there's always some tweaking to get it just right - but there's nothing inherently wrong with it. Skin tones are beautifully rendered as long as it was shot in proper lighting.

Now, if you positively don't like the Lightroom rendering, then the only logical answer is to use a raw processor that you do like. I don't know what Sony offers, but it will match the camera jpeg because it's the same raw processing engine.

As for the Lightroom camera matching profiles, you get a good clue of why it doesn't look good if you just glance at the histogram. From the smooth rolling hills you suddenly get steep cliffs, gaps and saw-toothed ridges. It's pretty obvious that some really radical curves have been applied to make it look like something it isn't. That alone tells me to avoid them.

Sign up

To post, reply, or follow discussions, please sign in with your Adobe ID.

Sign in to Adobe Community

To post, reply, or follow discussions, please sign in with your Adobe ID.

Scanning file for viruses.

This file cannot be downloaded