Skip to main content
Nadeem28230335k4xr
Known Participant
February 3, 2023
Answered

help, I'm trying to understand how to use Lr/Ps cloud and LrC together

  • February 3, 2023
  • 2 replies
  • 292 views

Hello.  I'm thinking of getting an Adobe cloud photography subscription that would allow me to use my iPad as my primary photo processing/editing device with Lr and Ps, syncing my raw photos and edits.  Then also having LrC on my desktop as a secondary device in the odd instance I need to use some plug-in or use printing features.

 

Is it possible to import my images to an album in Lr on ipad, then on LrC on my desktop sync those albums as, if I understand correctly, a collection, and not need to use a catalog in Lightroom Classic?

 

FYI in case it comes up, I do back up my raws to an external SSD.  I'm really looking for a mobile first solution.  I already sit at a desk in front of a computer 5 days a week for work, I don't want to keep doing that for my hobby (not a professional photog).

This topic has been closed for replies.
Correct answer Conrad_C
quote

Is it possible to import my images to an album in Lr on ipad, then on LrC on my desktop sync those albums as, if I understand correctly, a collection, and not need to use a catalog in Lightroom Classic?

By @Nadeem28230335k4xr

 

The part about not needing to use a catalog in Lightroom Classic isn’t possible. A catalog is needed to do anything in Lightroom Classic, and also, your cloud syncing has to be set up from one specific catalog.

quote

Hello.  I'm thinking of getting an Adobe cloud photography subscription that would allow me to use my iPad as my primary photo processing/editing device with Lr and Ps, syncing my raw photos and edits.  Then also having LrC on my desktop as a secondary device in the odd instance I need to use some plug-in or use printing features.

By @Nadeem28230335k4xr

 

This is possible. Two things to remember are:

Lightroom is cloud-first, so it will want to keep originals in the cloud.

Lightroom Classic is local-first, so it will want to keep originals locally.

 

That’s a basic conflict, so that two apps have a way of resolving it, you just have to be aware of how it will work.

 

You can go ahead and use the iPad as your mobile-first solution. As you import originals into Lightroom on iPad, Lightroom will upload the originals to the cloud for permanent storage.

 

If you then start Lightroom Classic and sync a catalog to your Creative Cloud account, Lightroom Classic will automatically download everything it finds in the cloud. You will then have local copies of everything and can back them up locally as usual.

 

In Lightroom Classic, all cloud-synced originals are listed in the All Synced Photographs automatic collection. If you want to use the cloud as your main storage, then this is the third important thing to remember: Don’t delete anything from All Synced Photographs, because it will disappear from the cloud and your iPad, and will only be available locally in Lightroom Classic.

 

To get that deleted original back into the cloud you might think you can just sync it back up from Lightroom Classic, but you should not do it that way, because of the fourth thing to remember: Lightroom Classic uploads only a Smart Preview, not the original. The only way to get the full resolution original back in the cloud permanently is to upload it from the Lightroom (not Classic) side.

 

If you can remember those four things, you should be OK with the workflow you want.

2 replies

Conrad_C
Community Expert
Conrad_CCommunity ExpertCorrect answer
Community Expert
February 3, 2023
quote

Is it possible to import my images to an album in Lr on ipad, then on LrC on my desktop sync those albums as, if I understand correctly, a collection, and not need to use a catalog in Lightroom Classic?

By @Nadeem28230335k4xr

 

The part about not needing to use a catalog in Lightroom Classic isn’t possible. A catalog is needed to do anything in Lightroom Classic, and also, your cloud syncing has to be set up from one specific catalog.

quote

Hello.  I'm thinking of getting an Adobe cloud photography subscription that would allow me to use my iPad as my primary photo processing/editing device with Lr and Ps, syncing my raw photos and edits.  Then also having LrC on my desktop as a secondary device in the odd instance I need to use some plug-in or use printing features.

By @Nadeem28230335k4xr

 

This is possible. Two things to remember are:

Lightroom is cloud-first, so it will want to keep originals in the cloud.

Lightroom Classic is local-first, so it will want to keep originals locally.

 

That’s a basic conflict, so that two apps have a way of resolving it, you just have to be aware of how it will work.

 

You can go ahead and use the iPad as your mobile-first solution. As you import originals into Lightroom on iPad, Lightroom will upload the originals to the cloud for permanent storage.

 

If you then start Lightroom Classic and sync a catalog to your Creative Cloud account, Lightroom Classic will automatically download everything it finds in the cloud. You will then have local copies of everything and can back them up locally as usual.

 

In Lightroom Classic, all cloud-synced originals are listed in the All Synced Photographs automatic collection. If you want to use the cloud as your main storage, then this is the third important thing to remember: Don’t delete anything from All Synced Photographs, because it will disappear from the cloud and your iPad, and will only be available locally in Lightroom Classic.

 

To get that deleted original back into the cloud you might think you can just sync it back up from Lightroom Classic, but you should not do it that way, because of the fourth thing to remember: Lightroom Classic uploads only a Smart Preview, not the original. The only way to get the full resolution original back in the cloud permanently is to upload it from the Lightroom (not Classic) side.

 

If you can remember those four things, you should be OK with the workflow you want.

Jim Wilde
Community Expert
Community Expert
February 3, 2023
quote

 

Is it possible to import my images to an album in Lr on ipad, then on LrC on my desktop sync those albums as, if I understand correctly, a collection, and not need to use a catalog in Lightroom Classic?


By @Nadeem28230335k4xr

 

Yes, you can use LrC on your desktop in conjunction with Lightroom, but you can't avoid the need for a catalog. Collections in LrC are simply one part of the overall catalog. Yes, if you add images to an album in Lightroom and then sync an LrC catalog with the cloud, a copy of all the images in the cloud will download into that LrC catalog, and any albums in Lightroom will appear as collections in LrC. But you cannot pick and choose which images or albums download into LrC.....once you enable the catalog to sync, everything in the cloud will automatically download into that catalog (and will be stored on your local hard drive in the location that you choose via the LrC Preferences>Lightroom Sync tab).