Skip to main content
Participating Frequently
January 2, 2019
Answered

How do you actually get support from Adobe?

  • January 2, 2019
  • 2 replies
  • 1327 views

I'm having the issue described in...

Lightroom CC: Ability to identify pictures not assigned to an album | Photoshop Family Customer Community

I've asked a perfectly reasonable question...

What is the recommended approach to sorting pictures into folders given missing functionality so you can't filter to determine what photos have not been allocated to a folder?

2 months later no reply.

How do you obtain actual support for this product? A process fundamentally doesn't work. But the only option is to raise a message in this forum. And that is completely ignored.

    This topic has been closed for replies.
    Correct answer 99jon

    Adobe has just released LRCC 2.2 and it is now possible to filter for pictures not in any album. See my blog for more information on the album: facet and other new features:

    Lightroom Updates – February 2019

    2 replies

    99jon
    99jonCorrect answer
    Legend
    February 12, 2019

    Adobe has just released LRCC 2.2 and it is now possible to filter for pictures not in any album. See my blog for more information on the album: facet and other new features:

    Lightroom Updates – February 2019

    john beardsworth
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    January 3, 2019

    You'll get support for making the app work - not so much for specific ways that you might want to use it. A bit like you can take the car back to the dealer if the power steering doesn't work, but don't expect them to tell you how to use the steering wheel. Here they can quite reasonably say "so what?" if you can't find pictures which aren't in an album. Sure, I can imagine why any organized person might want to do so, but it's not really a fundamental feature, is it?

    "What is the recommended approach to sorting pictures into folders given missing functionality so you can't filter to determine what photos have not been allocated to a folder?"

    If you want an answer, my first suggestion would be use terms more precisely - you seem to use "folders" for what LRCC calls "albums". LRCC uses "folders" for its mechanism to group albums. But assuming I have guessed what you want to do, there is no recommended approach. If you want to find which photos haven't been allocated to an (or do you mean any?) album, you can select multiple albums using the standard Ctrl/Cmd and Shift  modifiers. So select all the albums at once, then select all the visible images. Now go to All Photos - the unselected images are those not in any album. Maybe I am wrong but as LRCC lacks an Invert Selection command, I can't see any way (other than eyeballing) to select them. You are running up against LRCC's limited capabilities!

    bjashtonAuthor
    Participating Frequently
    January 3, 2019

    "The cloud-based service for people who love photography, Lightroom CC gives you everything you need to edit, organise, store and share your photos across desktop, mobile and web."

    [Buy Adobe Photoshop Lightroom CC | Photo editing and organising software ]

    Lightroom CC has Albums and Folders to organise photos. But any sensible process for sorting anything but a trivial number of photos into albums would require a check to ensure that none have got missed. So far nobody has been able to describe a process for doing that or another way to sort photos that doesn't need a such a check. So I'd argue the "everything" bit is over stated. The process of organising photos is lacking a fundamental capability.

    To use your analogy of the car. This is like buying a car with gears but then discovering it has no clutch so you can't actually use them. The car drives in first. The gear box is perfectly fine. But I had very reasonable advertised expectations of higher speeds. My feeling is that in this situation I'd definitely be entitled to take it back to the dealer and ask how you are meant to use the gears.

    Your approach is manual as it requires visually scanning all the photos looking for those that are not selected. While it may work for a relatively small number of photos it isn't going to scale or be practical over time.

    JohanElzenga
    Community Expert
    Community Expert
    January 3, 2019

    A better car analogy is perhaps that if you buy a Lada, don't expect it to drive 250 km/hour. Lightroom CC is a work in progress. What you want to do isn't easily possible. It may have better functionality for that one day, but not right now. You'll have to live with that, or switch to a product that does meet your expectations.

    -- Johan W. Elzenga